Mutual holding firms could convert to mutual insurers

Summary#

SB 982, Mutual Insurance Holding Companies – Conversion to Mutual Insurers, amends Maryland’s Insurance Article and adds a new section. It lets an eligible mutual insurance holding company convert its system into a mutual insurer under a plan approved by its members and the Insurance Commissioner. The stated goal is to set rules for that conversion. The law took effect October 1, 2026.

  • A holding company may use this route only if it directly or indirectly owns all the stock of a reorganized stock insurer.
  • The plan must convert the holding company’s membership interests into nontransferable membership interests in the mutual insurer. Future policyholders of the mutual insurer must become its members.
  • The plan must keep existing policies in effect, retire the stock insurer’s shares, dissolve the holding company and any intermediate stock holding company, and provide for surplus funds reasonably adequate to protect policyholders.
  • The holding company’s board and any intermediate stock holding company’s board must approve the plan. At least 75% of members who vote must also approve it.
  • The Insurance Commissioner reviews the plan. The Commissioner must approve a plan that meets the law and is equitable to the holding company’s members and the stock insurer’s policyholders, but may impose additional conditions.

What it means for you#

  • Policyholders: If a conversion happens, existing policies must remain in effect. The bill does not itself change policy prices or coverage terms.
  • Members of a mutual insurance holding company: If a conversion happens, your existing membership interest becomes a nontransferable membership interest in the new mutual insurer. The plan needs approval by at least 75% of members who vote.
  • Insurance companies: An eligible holding company may seek this conversion, but it must submit a plan and supporting material to the Commissioner at least 60 days before the proposed effective date.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill gives the Insurance Commissioner review powers; it does not create a new agency. It does not directly change taxes, fees, or public services.

Money#

The bill gives no overall cost estimate, but it allows the Commissioner to hire an outside expert at the holding company’s expense.

  • The plan must include a five-year operating plan, including any proposed transfers of assets or liabilities. The bill does not require a transfer.
  • No appropriation, fee, or fine is set out in the bill. No publicly available information is provided about likely review costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “equitable” or explain how much surplus is “reasonably adequate.”
  • The Commissioner may request other information, impose conditions, and hold a hearing. The bill does not set detailed decision standards or say when a hearing is required.
  • If the Commissioner does not disapprove the plan, it is approved 60 days after the plan and all required information are submitted. The bill does not explain how delays or incomplete submissions will be handled.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current Insurance Article, so it does not show how this route interacts with all existing conversion rules or programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it creates a defined route for an eligible holding company to become a mutual insurer, with member voting and regulatory review.
  • Keeping existing policies in effect could help avoid a gap in coverage during a conversion.
  • The five-year operating plan and the surplus requirement give the Commissioner information and a standard to consider before approving a conversion.
  • The Commissioner can impose additional conditions and can hire an outside expert to help review a plan.

Case against#

  • The bill allows approval by 75% of members who vote, rather than requiring approval from 75% of all members.
  • A plan can be approved after 60 days without an express approval notice, unless the Commissioner disapproves it. This may leave less time for review if information arrives late in the period.
  • The terms “equitable” and “reasonably adequate” are not defined, leaving important judgments to the Commissioner.
  • The bill does not set a limit on the cost of an outside expert that the holding company may have to pay.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1680595

    Passed43 members voted

    Third Reading Passed

    FOR · 43

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    43For

    • Democratic30
    • Republican13

    0Against

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.