Energy charges moved to General Fund

Summary#

HB-1640, the Maryland Energy Savings Guarantee Act, would amend and repeal provisions in several Maryland laws, including the Public Utilities, Environment, State Government, and Tax-General articles. It would bar certain state-imposed costs from appearing on utility bills and require state energy programs to be funded through General Fund appropriations. Its stated goal is to reduce energy costs by removing policy charges from utility bills; the bill is at first reading and is not law.

  • It would repeal provisions for the electric universal service program, energy-efficiency plans, building energy-efficiency standards, the renewable energy portfolio standard, and the public service company franchise tax.
  • It would repeal Maryland’s statutory provisions for the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and remove RGGI allowance proceeds and renewable-energy compliance fees as sources of money for the Strategic Energy Investment Fund.
  • A new rule would bar public service companies from putting state-mandated taxes, surcharges, riders, assessments, or other charges on electric or gas bills when they are not directly tied to the utility costs listed in the bill. The Public Service Commission (PSC) could not approve tariffs that recover state-imposed policy mandates.
  • State energy programs would have to be funded solely through direct appropriations from the State’s General Fund. The bill does not itself appropriate money.
  • It also changes related rules, including one method community solar organizations may use to verify a subscriber’s income eligibility.

What it means for you#

  • Electric and gas customers: Certain state policy costs could no longer be collected through utility bills. This does not guarantee lower bills: the bill does not estimate the effect on rates or say how costs might otherwise change.
  • Low-income customers: The bill repeals the statutory electric universal service program, which includes bill assistance, payment programs, service-termination protections, and help managing energy use. It also removes specified Strategic Energy Investment Fund support for energy assistance and rate relief. The bill does not set out a replacement for these provisions.
  • Utilities and energy suppliers: Public service companies would have to follow the new bill-charge limits. The PSC could not approve tariffs that recover state-imposed policy mandates. The bill also repeals the public service company franchise tax; it does not say how that repeal would affect utility rates.
  • Community solar organizations: They could no longer use participation in EmPOWER Maryland low- or moderate-income incentives as one listed way to verify income eligibility. Other listed verification methods would remain.
  • State government and taxpayers: The State would have to use General Fund appropriations to finance energy programs. That requirement does not itself create an appropriation or set a tax change.

Money#

The bill requires General Fund funding for state energy programs, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • It removes RGGI allowance proceeds and renewable-energy compliance fees as funding sources for the Strategic Energy Investment Fund. It also repeals the public service company franchise tax; the revenue effects are not estimated.
  • The bill does not specify how much the State would need to appropriate, how much revenue would be lost, or whether utility bills would fall. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill summary says the Governor must withdraw Maryland from RGGI. The operative text provided repeals the statute governing RGGI participation and allowance proceeds, but does not show a separate direction to withdraw. How the repeal would lead to withdrawal is unclear.
  • The bill does not explain whether or how the repealed energy assistance, efficiency, and building-standard provisions would be replaced.
  • It does not say which energy programs the General Assembly would fund, or how much money would be appropriated.
  • The full current statutes were not supplied, so I could not verify all the repealed provisions or how they interact with other current laws.
  • The bill is at first reading. Its passage is uncertain, and the text does not set out a start date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to separate energy-policy costs from utility service costs and make those policy costs visible in the State budget.
  • Requiring direct appropriations could give the General Assembly a clear choice about funding energy programs, rather than collecting money through utility bills.
  • Repealing specified mandates and surcharges could reduce charges on bills, although the bill does not guarantee that total bills would fall.

Case against#

  • The bill removes statutory support for electric bill assistance and service-termination protections without describing a replacement.
  • Requiring appropriations does not ensure that the programs will receive funding. If the General Assembly does not appropriate enough, services or projects could be reduced; the bill does not explain how that would be handled.
  • Removing funding sources and repealing efficiency, building-standard, and renewable-energy provisions could reduce or change those programs. The bill gives no estimate of the effects.
  • The bill’s stated requirement to withdraw from RGGI is not shown as a direct instruction in the operative text provided, leaving uncertainty about how that result would be achieved.