Bill would loosen land-use restrictions on property

Summary#

H-5664 is a proposed Massachusetts special act that would let the state’s Commissioner of Capital Asset Management and Maintenance release or amend use restrictions on former court property at 89 Summer Street and the district court parking lot at 0 Summer Street in Malden. The restrictions limit use to nonprofit recreational, educational or community purposes and related uses. The bill’s stated goal is to allow those restrictions to be changed or removed promptly; it does not require the commissioner to do so. The supplied status says the bill was favorably reported by committee and referred to House Ways and Means; it is not law.

  • The commissioner may change or remove the restrictions, despite other specified state laws and any conflicting general or special law.
  • For proposed sales or reuses, the commissioner must determine the consideration (the value or payment tied to the change) in consultation with Malden’s mayor.
  • When the city later conveys the property to a third-party developer, net proceeds are to be paid to the Commonwealth.
  • Net proceeds are calculated by subtracting the city’s $480,000 purchase price and eligible transaction costs from the sale price. If the result is negative, the Commonwealth does not have to pay the city.

What it means for you#

  • City of Malden: The bill would give the city a route to sell or reuse the property for purposes not allowed by the current restrictions, if the commissioner chooses to amend or release them. The bill does not require the city to sell or redevelop the property.
  • Commonwealth: The commissioner would have discretion over whether to change the restrictions and must consult the mayor when setting consideration. The bill directs net proceeds from a later conveyance to the Commonwealth.
  • People who might use the property: The bill does not guarantee public access, a particular future use, or a new service. A change to the restrictions could permit uses beyond the listed nonprofit purposes.

Money#

No cost estimate is available; the bill allows certain transaction costs to be deducted when calculating proceeds.

  • The calculation uses the city’s $480,000 purchase price in 2023 and subtracts costs such as appraisals, surveys, plans, professional fees and studies from the later sale price.
  • The bill does not state who specifically must transfer the net proceeds to the Commonwealth, though it says they are payable when the city conveys the property to a third party.
  • No appropriation, fee, fine or staffing estimate is included.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a process, deadline or criteria for the commissioner’s decision, or provide an appeal or reporting process.
  • It does not explain how the commissioner should calculate the consideration or how that amount relates to the separate net-proceeds calculation.
  • “All other proposed sale/reuses,” “ancillary uses” and “reasonable expenses” are not defined.
  • The bill does not say who would verify the sale price and deducted costs, or how disagreements about the calculation would be handled.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current law or deed text, so the full effect of the bill compared with all existing restrictions could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give the state and city a way to consider uses beyond the property’s existing nonprofit-use restrictions.
  • Allowing the commissioner to change the restrictions could make a sale or reuse possible without changing the restrictions for other property.
  • Requiring the net proceeds to go to the Commonwealth could return some value to the state after the city’s purchase price and eligible costs are accounted for.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the commissioner broad discretion but does not set decision criteria, a public process or a deadline.
  • It is unclear how the commissioner would set the consideration, and the bill does not require consultation with anyone other than the mayor.
  • Because eligible costs are deducted before calculating net proceeds, the amount paid to the Commonwealth could be reduced; the bill does not set limits or a review process for those costs.
  • The bill does not specify the property’s future use or require public access, so changing the restrictions would not itself ensure a community benefit.