UCC citation change narrows firearm suits

Summary#

HB 6349, titled “Commercial code: other; references to uniform commercial code in 1927 PA 372; revise,” would amend Section 15 of Michigan’s 1927 firearms law. Its stated goal is to revise a reference to the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). The bill is introduced and is not law; it would take effect only if HB 6347 is also enacted.

  • The supplied text lists MCL 440.12501 in the UCC citation for a limited exception to the restriction on political subdivisions bringing civil actions against firearm or ammunition producers.
  • That exception concerns a UCC-based claim when the political subdivision is the purchaser and owner of the firearm or ammunition.
  • The text also contains rules on firearm sales, storage information, civil actions, and penalties. But the bill’s title identifies the UCC reference as the change, and the supplied text does not mark additions and deletions.

What it means for you#

  • Political subdivisions: The UCC citation would be revised in the exception for a political subdivision that bought and owns the firearm or ammunition. The bill does not set up a new claims process.
  • Firearm and ammunition producers: The general restriction on political subdivisions bringing civil actions remains in the supplied text, along with listed exceptions. “Produce” includes activities such as manufacturing, designing, marketing, selling, and distributing. It is unclear whether the citation revision changes which UCC claims qualify.
  • Firearm buyers, dealers, and the public: The bill does not appear to change the firearm-sale, storage-information, or warning rules in Section 15. I could not verify those rules against current law because the parent Act was not supplied.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs is in the supplied material.

  • The bill states no spending amount and provides no estimate of costs or savings.
  • It does not state that it creates a fee or new staffing requirement.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not mark additions and deletions, so the exact wording being changed cannot be confirmed.
  • The current text of 1927 PA 372 was not supplied, so I could not verify what is already law or precisely how this bill differs.
  • It is unclear whether the revised citation changes which local-government claims qualify or only updates a reference.
  • The bill gives no start date of its own and depends on HB 6347 becoming law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that updating the UCC citation could make the law’s cross-reference more complete or accurate.
  • If the updated reference clarifies that the existing exception covers a particular UCC provision, it could give local governments and courts a clearer statutory reference for such claims.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain whether the citation change is only technical or changes the scope of the exception.
  • Without a clear comparison to current law, local governments, producers, and courts may not be able to tell what practical legal effect the revision is meant to have.
  • If the change is only a citation update, its practical effect may be limited. If it expands the exception, the supplied text does not explain that expansion.