Lien sales would update UCC citation

Summary#

HB 6377 would amend section 5 of Michigan’s Marina and Boatyard Storage Lien Act. It appears intended to revise a citation to the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) used in defining “commercially reasonable” for lien sales, but the supplied bill text contains two different UCC citation ranges. No goal is stated beyond revising the references.

  • The bill text includes one definition citing the UCC through MCL 440.9994 and another citing it through MCL 440.12501. It is unclear which reference the bill would change.
  • The section also sets out rules for marina and boatyard liens, including notice, sale, payment order, and access to stored property. Without the current Act, I could not verify which of these rules are new and which already apply.
  • The bill would take effect only if HB 6347 is enacted. The supplied materials do not explain what that bill would do.

What it means for you#

  • Marina and boatyard operators: The bill text does not clearly show a new duty or power beyond the apparent citation change. The section says an operator may sell property after a default of more than 180 days, subject to notice and sale requirements, but I could not verify whether those rules would change.
  • Property owners and lienholders: The text includes notice and sale protections, and says an owner remains liable for any shortfall after a sale. I could not verify whether the bill changes these existing rules.
  • Buyers at a lien sale: The text says a buyer takes property free of the owner’s and recorded lienholders’ rights. I could not verify whether this is new.
  • Anyone affected by a “commercially reasonable” sale: The bill’s two different UCC citation ranges make it unclear which statutory text the definition would point to.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill text does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, staffing level, or public cost estimate.
  • No fiscal note or budget material was supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text gives two different citation ranges for the definition of “commercially reasonable.” It does not make clear which one is intended to change.
  • The current Act was not supplied, so the available material does not show which lien-sale rules are new, if any.
  • The bill is tied to HB 6347, but that bill’s text and effect were not supplied.
  • The supplied material gives no start date or explanation of how the changed reference would affect sale disputes.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that updating a UCC citation could make the Act’s reference clearer or align it with the intended UCC provisions.
  • If the two citation ranges are meant to point to the same definition, resolving the mismatch could reduce uncertainty about the standard for a lien sale.
  • The bill appears narrow: its title and text focus on UCC references, not on creating a new program or changing the basic lien-sale process.

Case against#

  • The bill text itself contains two different citation ranges, so it may not resolve the uncertainty it appears intended to address.
  • Without the current Act or a clear comparison of the old and proposed wording, readers cannot tell exactly what legal change the citation would make.
  • It is unclear how the change would interact with HB 6347, which must also be enacted for HB 6377 to take effect.