Land contracts update UCC references

Summary#

HB 6376 would amend section 8 of Michigan’s 1879 law on land-sale contracts. Its stated purpose is to revise references to the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). The bill appears to update wording and citations while retaining the existing rules for land contract mortgages; I could not verify the current law because the parent Act was not supplied.

  • The section says a document sufficient to be a real estate mortgage can serve as a land contract mortgage against the seller’s (vendor’s) or buyer’s (vendee’s) interest.
  • It says a land contract mortgage must be made, acknowledged and recorded in the same way as a real estate mortgage, and need not specify whether it covers the vendor’s or vendee’s interest.
  • It says recording perfects the mortgage without a UCC filing, notice to the other party, or possession of the original land contract. It also sets a priority rule, subject to the same exceptions that apply to real estate mortgages. The supplied text does not make clear whether the bill changes these rules.
  • The bill revises wording and UCC citations, but the supplied text appears to combine old and new wording, so the exact edits are unclear.
  • The bill takes effect only if HB 6347 is enacted. It is introduced and is not law.

What it means for you#

  • People with a land contract, or with an interest secured by one: The bill does not clearly change how a land contract mortgage is made, recorded or prioritized. Those rules appear in the amended section, but the supplied text does not establish which parts are new.
  • People recording these documents: The section says land contract mortgages are recorded like real estate mortgages. The bill does not appear to create a new application, review or approval process.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or who can enter a land contract.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate and does not identify spending, fees, fines, or staffing requirements.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text runs old and new wording together. It does not show exactly which words or UCC references are being changed.
  • The UCC citation in the supplied text is unclear, including whether it adds a reference to MCL 440.12501.
  • The current text of the 1879 law was not supplied, so the exact difference from current law could not be checked.
  • HB 6376 takes effect only if HB 6347 is enacted, but the supplied material does not explain HB 6347’s contents or timing.
  • The bill text provided does not state a start date if the condition is met.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that updated wording and UCC references could make the statute easier to read and keep its legal references current.
  • Keeping the stated recording and priority rules could offer a clear way to perfect a land contract mortgage without a separate UCC filing.
  • The bill does not appear to create a new process for people to navigate.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the supplied text does not make the exact changes clear, especially in the UCC citation. Unclear references can make it harder to know how the law applies.
  • It is not possible from the supplied material to tell whether any of the existing recording or priority rules are meant to change in practice.
  • The bill depends on HB 6347, so its effect and start date depend on another bill’s enactment.