Insurance division wording updated, citation changed

Summary#

HB 6375 would amend section 5511 of Michigan’s Insurance Code of 1956, which deals with what happens when an insurer divides. The bill appears to clarify wording and update a reference to the Uniform Commercial Code; it does not appear to change the division rules themselves. Its stated goal is not given in the supplied material.

  • It replaces several pronouns with explicit references to the “dividing insurer,” “new insurer,” or shareholders.
  • It appears to change the cited Uniform Commercial Code range from MCL 440.1101–440.9994 to MCL 440.1101–440.12501.
  • It does not create a new agency, program, benefit, tax, or fee.
  • It would take effect only if HB 6347 is also enacted. HB 6375 is introduced and is not law.

What it means for you#

  • Insurers: The section as amended still describes what happens to an insurer’s existence, assets, liabilities, shares, and contracts when it divides. The supplied text does not show a change to those rules beyond the wording and citation edits above.
  • Insurers with collateral covered by a financing statement: The text says an allocation of that collateral to a new insurer is not effective until a new financing statement naming the new insurer as debtor takes effect under the Uniform Commercial Code.
  • Policyholders and other people with contracts: The text says an insurer division is not an assignment of an insurance policy, annuity, reinsurance agreement, or other contract. The bill does not appear to change that rule.
  • Other members of the public: No direct change to individual rights or duties is apparent from the supplied text.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate of public spending, savings, staffing, or costs to insurers or others.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the Insurance Code is not supplied, so the full difference between this bill and current law cannot be independently checked.
  • The bill’s redline appears to change the Uniform Commercial Code citation’s endpoint, but the supplied text does not explain why.
  • The material does not explain the bill’s purpose or whether the citation change is intended to affect how the existing rules are applied.
  • The bill’s effect depends on HB 6347, whose text is not supplied.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that naming the insurer or shareholders directly may make the section easier to read and reduce confusion about what its pronouns refer to.
  • Updating the cited range may make the reference match the intended scope of the Uniform Commercial Code.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the supplied material does not explain what problem the wording or citation changes solve.
  • The bill appears to make mainly technical changes, so it may leave any practical issues with insurer divisions untouched.
  • The bill cannot take effect on its own; its effect depends on the separate HB 6347 becoming law.