Health facilities face tougher criminal checks

Summary#

HB 6401 would amend Michigan’s Public Health Code, which already sets criminal-history rules for certain health facilities. It appears to change which convictions disqualify people and how long some convictions count; the stated goal is not given in the supplied material. The bill is introduced, not law, and would take effect 90 days after enactment only if HB 6400 and HB 6402 also become law.

  • The covered facilities are nursing homes, county medical care facilities, hospices, hospitals with swing-bed services, homes for the aged, and home health agencies.
  • The bill text bars those facilities from employing, contracting with, or granting clinical privileges to people with regular direct access to patients or residents if they meet listed disqualification criteria.
  • The amendment text appears to set a 15-year waiting period for specified serious felonies, a 10-year period for other felonies, and a 10-year period for listed misdemeanors. It also sets shorter periods for other misdemeanor categories.
  • Facilities and staffing agencies must still arrange criminal-history checks before employment or privileges, subject to listed exceptions and conditional-employment rules. Applicants cannot be charged for the checks.

What it means for you#

  • Covered facilities and staffing agencies: They would have to apply the bill’s disqualification rules and existing check requirements. Knowingly and willfully failing to conduct required checks can bring a misdemeanor penalty of up to one year in jail, a $5,000 fine, or both.
  • Applicants and workers: The rules apply to people seeking employment, independent contracts, or clinical privileges who regularly have direct access to patients or residents. Direct access includes access to patients’ or residents’ property, financial information, medical records, treatment information, or identifying information. A person may be conditionally employed before results arrive, but the bill sets conditions, including supervision unless specified safeguards are met.
  • People already working in these facilities: The text requires covered workers to agree to report certain arraignments, convictions, and findings, and to provide fingerprints if none are on file. Reporting an arraignment alone is not cause for termination.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change patient services, benefits, or taxes.

Money#

The bill requires facilities or staffing agencies to pay for most criminal-history checks, but no overall cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • Applicants and prospective contractors cannot be charged for the check.
  • The state pays or reimburses check costs for homes for the aged, subject to annual limits of 40 checks for homes with fewer than 100 beds and 50 for homes with 100 or more beds.
  • The Department may charge staffing agencies a one-time fee of up to $100 to access the web-based system.
  • The bill does not state how many checks will be needed or estimate staffing or administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not include the current version of the amended section or preserved strike-through and underline formatting. So the exact changes from current law cannot be verified; the waiting-period changes above are based on the apparent amendment wording.
  • The bill does not explain how it would interact with HB 6400 or HB 6402, whose enactment is required for this bill to take effect.
  • It does not set new timelines or appeal rules. It refers to appeal procedures in another section, which was not supplied.
  • No fiscal estimate or explanation of the bill’s stated goal is provided.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that criminal-history checks and disqualification rules can help protect patients and residents who may be vulnerable or have sensitive information and property at risk.
  • Different waiting periods for different kinds of convictions could be seen as a way to distinguish between offenses by type and seriousness.
  • Continuing to prohibit applicants from paying for checks avoids shifting that required cost onto them.

Case against#

  • One concern is that longer waiting periods or a new waiting period for other felonies could keep people from covered-facility work for years after completing their sentences.
  • The text does not explain why the particular waiting periods or offense categories were chosen, or how they balance patient safety with applicants’ ability to return to work.
  • Facilities and the state may face costs for checks and administration, but the materials do not estimate those costs.