Ads would require source disclosures linked to records

Summary#

HB 6439 would amend the Michigan Campaign Finance Act, 1976 PA 388, and add rules for paid political advertisements. Its stated aim is greater transparency about factual claims based on official public records. It is an introduced bill, not law; the text gives no start date, and passage is uncertain.

  • A paid or sponsored political ad making a verifiable claim based on an official public record would generally have to include a clear source disclosure that links directly to the record.
  • An ad could not say or imply that a legislator voted for or against a bill without citing the legislator’s final passage vote. If it refers to an earlier procedural action, it must say that the action was not final passage and disclose the final outcome—or say no final passage vote occurred.
  • The Secretary of State could prioritize review of these ads in the 60 days before an election. Review would be limited to disclosure requirements and checking official records, not judging opinions, fairness, or political meaning.
  • A person who receives written notice of an omission or clerical or formatting error could avoid a fine by stopping the noncompliant version and starting a good-faith correction within 48 hours—or 24 hours in the 60 days before an election. This cure would not apply to specified serious problems, including mischaracterizing a vote.
  • Violations could lead to an order to correct or stop the ad, a corrective disclosure, and a civil fine. The bill also lets the Secretary of State modify complaint-review and decision procedures under the Act, but does not spell out those changes.

What it means for you#

  • Candidates, committees, political organizations, and other people who pay for or sponsor ads: If an ad makes a record-based factual claim, it would generally need a source disclosure. The disclosure must identify relevant legislative information and link to the official record; an audio-only ad or constrained format can use specified alternatives.
  • People who run political ads: The rules cover paid or sponsored communications across media, including online ads, mass texts and emails, and compensated influencer content. A repeat violation within four years, a knowing violation, or a violation during the 60 days before an election could face the higher fine limit.
  • People expressing views without paying for or sponsoring an ad: Opinion, commentary, satire, parody, and editorial analysis that do not assert record-based facts are excluded. Unpaid communications by individuals acting independently are also excluded.
  • News and live-event audiences: News, editorial, or commentary content is excluded unless it is a paid political ad. Live events and unedited recordings are excluded unless someone specifically pays to disseminate the recording as a covered ad.
  • Voters and the public: Ads covered by the rules would have to point to official records for covered factual claims. The bill does not create a general fact-checking system for political opinions or predictions.
  • The Secretary of State: The office would handle the limited review described above and could seek an injunction in court if it finds the specified risk of irreparable harm before an election. It could ask a nonpartisan legislative entity or a House or Senate clerk to confirm what an official record says.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public costs.

  • The bill authorizes civil fines: generally, no more than the lower of the ad’s documented production and distribution cost or $10,000. For specified serious or repeated violations, the limit rises to the lower of three times that cost or $50,000.
  • The person responsible for an ad would have to keep and provide, on request, records reasonably needed to determine its attributable cost.
  • The bill adds review and possible court work for the state, but gives no staffing or cost estimate. People who pay for covered ads could face recordkeeping and correction costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give an effective date.
  • It allows the Secretary of State to modify complaint-review and decision procedures, but does not specify what procedures may change.
  • The definition of source disclosure lists details such as a bill or resolution number and roll-call identifier. How those details apply to claims about records that are not roll-call votes is not clear.
  • The bill does not specify how quickly the Secretary of State must complete a review under the new rules.
  • The supplied material does not include the unamended Campaign Finance Act, so the full effect of changes to existing complaint and enforcement procedures could not be verified against current law.

Case for#

  • A direct link to an official record could help voters check claims about legislative votes and actions for themselves.
  • The rules distinguish factual claims about public records from opinions, predictions, and policy arguments, and limit the Secretary of State’s review accordingly.
  • The correction option gives people a way to fix some omissions or clerical errors without a fine, while excluding serious misrepresentations from that option.
  • Higher fine limits for specified violations could make compliance more consequential during election periods.

Case against#

  • The required disclosures and recordkeeping could add cost and work for people and organizations that pay for political ads.
  • It may be difficult to tell when an ad’s wording is a record-based factual claim rather than an inference or policy characterization.
  • The Secretary of State could change complaint procedures under the bill, but the permitted changes and safeguards are not specified in the text.
  • The bill permits court action to stop an ad before an election under a demanding harm test. How that power would be used is not clear from the bill.