Commercial Records Requests Could Take Longer

Summary#

Michigan Senate Bill 1232 would amend the state’s Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), not create a new law. Its stated aim is to set rules for requests made for commercial purposes. The bill is introduced and referred to committee; it is not law.

  • A requester would have to say in a written FOIA request whether it is for a commercial purpose.
  • A public body would have up to 21 business days to respond to a commercial-purpose request, instead of the 5-business-day deadline that the bill keeps for other requests. It could extend either deadline once, by up to 10 business days.
  • “Commercial purpose” would mean using any part of a public record or its information for sale, resale, or to solicit or advertise sales or services. Requests made by news media, nonprofit, scientific, and academic organizations would not count as commercial-purpose requests.
  • The bill keeps the public body’s FOIA coordinator responsible for accepting and processing requests and approving denials.
  • The bill also changes wording in fee and coordinator provisions. The available material does not show which of those wording changes would alter current rules.

What it means for you#

  • People and organizations making requests: You would have to identify whether your written request is for a commercial purpose. If it is, the public body would have longer to respond. The bill does not change the 5-business-day deadline for other requests.
  • News media, nonprofit, scientific, and academic organizations: Your written requests would be excluded from the bill’s definition of commercial purpose.
  • Public bodies: Their FOIA coordinators would handle requests under the new timing and commercial-purpose rules.
  • Requesters generally: The bill does not create a new right to records or a new fee schedule. The bill text retains existing fee provisions, but the current FOIA text was not supplied, so I could not verify all fee changes against current law.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal note is in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state a new appropriation, tax, fee, or fine.
  • Public bodies would have to apply the new request and response rules, but the bill gives no estimate of staff time or cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what happens if a requester does not state whether a request is for a commercial purpose.
  • It does not define “news media,” “nonprofit organizations,” “scientific organizations,” or “academic organizations.”
  • The supplied text gives no start date.
  • The current Freedom of Information Act was not supplied, so the full effect of the wording changes to fees and coordinator duties cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • A longer response period could give public bodies more time to handle requests involving commercial use.
  • The bill draws a line between commercial use and requests from named types of organizations, including news media and academic organizations.
  • Requiring requesters to identify commercial purpose could make it clearer which response deadline applies.

Case against#

  • Commercial-purpose requesters could wait substantially longer for a response: up to 21 business days before any extension.
  • The bill does not explain how public bodies should classify requests when the purpose is unclear or disputed.
  • The named organization categories are not defined, leaving room for uncertainty about who qualifies for the exception.