Rental Marketplace Guarantees Would Require Insurance

Summary#

HB 6458 would amend Michigan’s Insurance Code of 1956 by adding rules for “rental home marketplace guarantees.” It is introduced and is not law. The title says the bill would provide for these guarantees; no further statement of its goal is supplied.

  • A marketplace, or its affiliate or representative, could offer a guarantee in Michigan only if it posts the terms on its website and insures every guarantee through a qualifying reimbursement insurance policy.
  • The guarantee must be written in clear language, explain its terms and limits, and include statements that it is not insurance and that the provider’s obligations are backed by an insurance policy.
  • If the provider fails to perform within 180 days after proof of loss is filed, the guarantee must say the platform user may claim directly against the insurer, subject to the policy.
  • The insurer must cover the provider’s obligations under the guarantee if the provider defaults. The provider is the insurer’s agent, and the insurer may seek repayment from the provider.
  • A compliant guarantee would not be treated as insurance and would not have to follow Michigan insurance laws. The bill does not state when it would take effect.

What it means for you#

  • People using a rental home marketplace: If you are the beneficiary or holder of a guarantee, its terms must be available on the provider’s website. The guarantee must include a route to claim directly against the insurer after the 180-day period described above, but any claim remains subject to the policy.
  • Providers: A covered provider must insure all its guarantees, disclose their terms, and not make false or misleading statements or deliberately leave out material information in an offer or advertisement. The bill covers marketplaces that connect users to share property and offer guarantees only as an activity ancillary (secondary) to their primary legitimate business.
  • Insurers: An insurer issuing the required policy must cover the provider’s obligations if the provider defaults or fails to perform. Ending the policy would not remove responsibility for guarantees issued before the termination takes effect. The insurer may seek indemnification (repayment) or use subrogation (take over the provider’s claim-related rights) against the provider.
  • The public: The bill does not create a government-backed benefit or make these guarantees insurance. It applies only to guarantees meeting the bill’s definitions; it excludes the state and its political subdivisions as marketplaces.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of public or private costs.

  • Providers must insure every covered guarantee, but the bill gives no premium amounts or estimate of the cost to providers.
  • The bill does not appropriate public money or set a fee or tax.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “share property,” “ancillary,” or “primary legitimate business,” which affect which platforms and guarantees are covered.
  • It does not set detailed claim-handling steps, deadlines beyond the stated 180-day period, appeal rights, or oversight and enforcement procedures.
  • It does not state how the new rules would interact with other existing laws or programs. The current Insurance Code text was not supplied, so the existing rules and what would be new could not be verified.
  • The bill does not state a start date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that users would have an insurance-backed source of payment if a provider failed to meet its guarantee obligations.
  • Requiring clear terms and barring false or misleading offers could help users understand what a guarantee covers and what it excludes.
  • The direct-claim statement could give a user a way to seek payment from the insurer if the provider does not perform within the stated period.

Case against#

  • One concern is that guarantees would be exempt from Michigan insurance laws if providers comply with this section, even though users may rely on them for payment.
  • The bill allows guarantees to contain limits, exceptions, conditions, and exclusions, but does not set minimum coverage standards.
  • The direct claim route is subject to the policy and follows a 180-day period; the bill does not explain how claims or disputes would be handled in detail.
  • The bill does not explain how compliance would be checked or what consequences would follow a violation.