Homebuyer Savings Cap Would Double

Summary#

HB 6456 would amend Michigan’s 2022 Michigan First-Time Home Buyer Savings Program Act. It would extend the period for opening these accounts, raise their maximum balance and start adjusting that limit for inflation; the stated goal is to change the program’s sunset and account limit. The bill is introduced and would not take effect unless HB 5973 is also enacted.

  • The program would remain in the Department, with its powers and duties exercised by the state treasurer or the treasurer’s designee.
  • An individual could open and designate an account through December 31, 2031, instead of December 31, 2026. The account must be for eligible costs to buy a single-family home in Michigan and have one designated first-time home buyer as beneficiary at a time.
  • The maximum account balance would rise from $50,000 to $100,000. Starting January 1, 2028, and each January 1 after that, the limit would be adjusted by the prior year’s percentage increase in the U.S. Consumer Price Index.
  • Cash and marketable securities could be contributed, including by people other than the account holder, subject to the balance limit. Earnings could continue to accrue after the account reaches the limit without counting as exceeding it.
  • The bill retains the stated tax exemptions for contributions, interest and qualified withdrawals; it does not create a new tax exemption in the supplied text.

What it means for you#

  • People saving for a first home: If the bill takes effect, you could open an account for a qualifying beneficiary through 2031. The account would have a higher balance limit, with later inflation adjustments. The beneficiary must be a first-time home buyer, and the money is for eligible costs to buy a single-family residence in Michigan.
  • Account holders and contributors: Other people may contribute, subject to the limit. The account holder may name themself as beneficiary and may change the beneficiary, but only one beneficiary can be designated at a time.
  • Joint account holders: The bill text allows joint ownership if the holders file a joint Michigan income tax return. The supplied text does not establish whether the wording change to this rule changes who qualifies.
  • Others: The bill does not directly change home prices, mortgage terms or who qualifies as a first-time home buyer. It does not require anyone to open an account.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill raises the account balance limit and provides for future inflation adjustments. It gives no estimate of how many accounts would reach the limit or of the resulting tax effects.
  • The program’s powers and duties remain with the treasurer or designee. The bill gives no staffing or administrative cost estimate.
  • The bill retains tax exemptions for contributions, interest and qualified withdrawals. No estimate of the revenue effect is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Act is not supplied, so the current law and the full definitions and eligibility rules could not be checked against it.
  • The bill does not explain how the program’s account rules are administered, or provide timelines, appeal rights or reporting requirements.
  • It does not say how the new limit and opening period would interact with accounts already open.
  • The bill does not specify an effective date apart from making its effect conditional on HB 5973 being enacted. Its passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a higher balance limit gives account holders more room to save for eligible home-purchase costs.
  • Extending the period for opening accounts could let more people use the program.
  • Adjusting the limit for inflation could help prevent it from losing value over time.

Case against#

  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate for the tax exemptions or explain how many people might use them. That makes the public cost difficult to assess.
  • The bill does not explain how the account rules are administered or how the program’s results would be measured.
  • The account limit could rise over time, but the bill gives no estimate of the future limits or their tax effects.