Quarterly Reports for Grant and Contract Spending

Summary#

SB-1220 would amend Michigan’s Management and Budget Act by adding a new reporting section. Its apparent goal is to make spending under certain state contracts and grants more transparent; the bill does not state a separate goal or guarantee that result.

  • Awardees covered by the bill would have to report to the state agency that awarded the contract or grant at least once every quarter, for the contract or grant’s duration.
  • Reports would include an accounting of state money spent, a receipt for every payment made using that money, and the purpose of each payment—including whether it furthered a lawsuit against a government entity.
  • Awardees would also have to provide names and addresses of governing-board members and, for some types of awardee, owners. The department would have to publish information it receives on a public website with specified search features.
  • Awardees would have to keep the submitted information for at least seven years. The department or another state agency may audit spending.
  • If a report is more than 30 days late, the awarding agency must stop further payments until the awardee complies. After three or more failures to comply, the awardee would be ineligible for state contracts or grants for three years.

What it means for you#

  • Awardees: If covered, you would have to submit the reports and identifying information quarterly, keep the records, and provide receipts for every payment made with state money, regardless of purpose.
  • State agencies and the department: Agencies would have to send received information to the department and stop payments when the bill’s late-reporting condition is met. The department would have to publish information on a public website. State agencies and the department may audit spending.
  • People paid by awardees: The site would have to be searchable by the name of any person paid with state money. The bill does not specify what information about those people must appear in search results.
  • Public: The bill would create a public website for the submitted information. It does not create a new independent agency or a new service for members of the public.
  • The bill’s definition excludes a contract or grant “described in this article.” The supplied materials do not identify which contracts or grants that excludes, so not every state contract or grant can be assumed to be covered.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimated cost or revenue effect.

  • The bill requires state agencies and the department to handle reports and publish information, but gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
  • It authorizes audits but does not require a specific number or set an audit budget.
  • It creates no fee, fine, or direct payment to awardees in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Management and Budget Act was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which reporting duties, audit powers, or contract rules already exist, or precisely which grants and contracts are excluded.
  • The bill does not explain how the website should handle receipts or other information that may identify people, or whether any information may be withheld.
  • It does not define how a “failure to comply” is counted, including whether separate missing items in one report count as separate failures.
  • It does not set rules for checking reports, resolving disputes, correcting errors, or appealing a finding of non-compliance.
  • It gives no start date and does not say how the reporting rules would apply to contracts or grants already underway. The bill is introduced and passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that quarterly accounts and receipts could make it easier for agencies and the public to see how state money was spent.
  • Publishing awardee and payment information could make spending easier to search and compare.
  • Seven-year recordkeeping and the power to audit could help agencies check whether reported spending matches the records.
  • Stopping payments for late reports and barring repeat non-compliers could give awardees a strong reason to submit the required information.

Case against#

  • Requiring a receipt for every payment, regardless of purpose, could create substantial reporting and recordkeeping work for awardees and state agencies; the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • Publishing the information received could expose detailed financial records and names and addresses of board members or owners. The bill does not explain what information may be withheld.
  • A missed report could stop state payments, and three or more failures could bar an awardee from state contracts or grants for three years. The bill does not set out a process for challenging a finding or accounting for the seriousness of a failure.
  • The exclusion for contracts or grants described elsewhere in the Act is unclear from the supplied materials, making the proposal’s coverage hard to assess.