Auditor would broaden government misconduct reporting

Summary#

HB 3510 would repeal and replace Missouri law, section 29.221, concerning the state auditor’s duties for reports of improper governmental activity. Its stated goal, reflected in the bill title, is to modify those duties. The available material does not show which parts would be new compared with current law.

  • The auditor must provide ways to report allegations, including a phone hotline, email and internet access, and must periodically publicize how to report.
  • The auditor must receive and initially review allegations about state agencies, political subdivisions, and their officers or employees. The auditor may investigate allegations they consider credible.
  • The bill directs the auditor to refer certain allegations to other authorities, including criminal misconduct, ethics-law violations and election-law violations.
  • The auditor may examine records of certain organizations that receive public funds through state-agency subgrants or allocations, to check receipt and use of those funds.

What it means for you#

  • People making reports: You may choose to remain anonymous unless you affirmatively consent to disclosure of your identity.
  • State and local agencies, officers and employees: The auditor must initially review allegations about them within the auditor’s authority. The bill does not require an investigation of every allegation; the auditor may investigate allegations considered credible.
  • Organizations receiving allocated or subgranted public funds: The auditor may examine their books and records, but only to the extent needed to oversee receipt and expenditure of those funds and determine whether they were properly used.
  • General public: The bill concerns reporting and oversight. It does not itself create a benefit, tax, fee or fine.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The auditor would have to provide and publicize reporting channels and receive and initially review allegations. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Investigations and examination of recipients’ records may also require resources; the bill gives no estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of section 29.221 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what duties or powers already exist and what the bill would change.
  • The bill does not set timelines, investigation standards, appeal rights or reporting requirements for the auditor.
  • It does not define “credible” allegations or “improper governmental activities.”
  • The bill does not explain how the auditor would choose between referring a matter to the attorney general or a county prosecutor, or how referrals would be followed up.
  • The bill does not specify how many recipient organizations could be examined or how the limit on examining records would be applied.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people would have several ways to report suspected government wrongdoing, including a way to remain anonymous.
  • Requiring an initial review, while allowing investigation of allegations the auditor considers credible, could help direct attention to reports the auditor judges worth investigating.
  • Referring matters to agencies with responsibility for criminal, ethics or election-law issues could place them with authorities assigned to handle those subjects.
  • Examining records of recipients of allocated public funds could help check whether those funds were properly received and spent.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “credible” or set rules for deciding which allegations to investigate, leaving important decisions to the auditor’s judgment.
  • It does not set timelines or explain what happens after an initial review, investigation or referral.
  • The authority to examine records reaches some private or semiprivate recipients of public funds. The bill limits the examination to what is needed to oversee and check those funds, but does not explain how that limit would be applied.
  • Because the current law was not supplied, the available material does not show whether the bill adds new duties or mainly restates existing ones.