Bill would purge voter rolls via citizenship checks

Summary#

HB 3493 would amend Missouri’s election laws by replacing section 115.158 of the Missouri Revised Statutes and adding sections 115.028 and 115.220. Its apparent goal is to maintain voter registration lists by using death records, agency data, and citizenship-status checks; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The Department of Health and Senior Services would have to send the Secretary of State monthly reports of death certificates. The Secretary would notify local election authorities, which would have to remove the reported names from voter rolls.
  • The Secretary would have to arrange to use the federal SAVE program to check citizenship status, including checks at least twice a year and when available data flags a new registration.
  • Before action based on SAVE information, election authorities would have to give written notice and at least 30 days to respond. A registered voter could not be removed within 90 days of a federal election unless the voter requests it or a final judgment finds the voter ineligible.
  • State agencies would have to provide data the Secretary considers necessary, subject to federal law. Circuit clerks would have to send monthly lists of people who identified themselves as noncitizens during jury qualification; election authorities would have to remove listed people who are on the voter rolls and mail them notice afterward.
  • The Secretary would have to protect confidential data and keep aggregate counts of SAVE notices and outcomes. The bill also authorizes agreements to share data with other states or groups of states.

What it means for you#

  • Registered voters: If a SAVE check raises a concern, you would get written notice and at least 30 days to respond before action based on that information. The bill does not describe an appeal process.
  • People on a circuit clerk’s noncitizen list: If the Secretary finds your name on the voter list, the local election authority must remove it and mail notice afterward. The bill does not give this process the same express advance notice and response period as the SAVE process.
  • State agencies and circuit clerks: State agencies would have to supply requested data, and circuit clerks would have to send the specified monthly lists.
  • The Secretary of State and local election authorities: They would have new data-sharing, checking, notice, reporting, and list-maintenance duties.
  • Current law comparison: The current text of section 115.158 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the voter-registration system language in the replacement section is new. The bill also does not directly change voting methods or create a new benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns data, verification, notice, and reporting duties to state and local offices, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It does not specify a new appropriation, tax, or fee.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define when data indicates “potential noncitizenship” or what evidence is acceptable to prove citizenship; it leaves those details to rules.
  • It is unclear how the SAVE process and the separate circuit-clerk list process would work together, especially if the records conflict.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for state agencies to provide data; the Secretary of State would set the schedule.
  • It does not explain how a person can challenge a removal, or how errors would be corrected under the circuit-clerk list process.
  • The bill gives no start date or cost estimate. Its current status is introduced, so passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that regular use of death records and agency data could help keep voter rolls current.
  • SAVE checks could help election officials verify citizenship status, while advance notice and time to respond provide a safeguard against some errors.
  • Sharing data among agencies and states could give the Secretary more information for maintaining the statewide list.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a person could be removed based on a name on a circuit-clerk list, with notice sent only after removal; the bill does not specify an advance response period for that route.
  • The bill does not explain how officials would prevent mistaken matches or resolve conflicting records, beyond the safeguards stated for SAVE-based action.
  • The Secretary would decide what state-agency data is necessary and set its delivery schedule; the bill gives few details about limits or oversight of those decisions.
  • The new duties could require staff or technology spending, but the bill provides no estimate.