Lawmakers to study public safety

Summary#

HJ 57 was a Montana joint resolution, not a bill changing the Statewide Public Safety Communications System Act. It failed, so it did not create a study or change the system. Its goal was to have legislators examine the system’s operation, funding, and role in responses to extreme weather and disasters.

  • The resolution asked the Legislative Council to assign an interim or statutory committee to study the system and propose legislation to improve and sustain it.
  • The proposed study covered governance, system performance and coverage, interoperability, new technology, staffing, and long-term costs and funding.
  • If a committee were assigned, it would have to consult the Department of Justice, the system’s advisory council, local and tribal governments, state agencies, federal partners, dispatch centers, and industry experts.
  • The study was to be completed before September 15, 2026, with results reported to the 70th Legislature.

What it means for you#

  • Emergency responders and public safety agencies: The resolution would not have upgraded equipment, expanded coverage, or changed how agencies communicate. It proposed studying those issues.
  • Local governments, tribal governments, and other named groups: They were among the groups a committee would have to consult if the study went ahead. The resolution did not set out how that consultation would work.
  • Montana residents and taxpayers: It would not directly change emergency services, create a new communications system, or provide new funding. The resolution’s background describes an existing system run under the Department of Justice.
  • Current law: The resolution proposed reviewing the Statewide Public Safety Communications System Act; it did not amend that Act.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material for carrying out the study.

  • The resolution did not appropriate money or set a study budget.
  • Its background says a prior $3.75 million annual appropriation ended in July 2023 and describes a funding shortfall at the end of fiscal year 2027. The resolution proposed examining future costs and funding options, but did not choose or fund one.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution did not specify how much the study would cost or what staff and other resources it would need. No publicly available information.
  • It did not choose a committee, and because the resolution failed, no committee was assigned under it.
  • It did not require particular recommendations or require the Legislature to adopt any recommendations.
  • It did not specify how participating agencies or communities would be involved beyond requiring consultation if the study took place.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that a study could give legislators a shared picture of system coverage, performance, and future needs before they make decisions.
  • Examining costs and possible funding sources could help legislators consider the system’s long-term sustainability.
  • Consulting local, tribal, state, and federal users could bring different needs and experiences into that review.
  • Reviewing interoperability and newer technologies could help identify where communications across agencies or jurisdictions may need improvement.

Case against#

  • The resolution would study problems but would not itself improve coverage, equipment, or emergency communications.
  • It proposed a broad review without specifying a study budget, required recommendations, or what action would follow the report.
  • The background identifies a future funding shortfall, but the resolution would not provide money or settle who should pay.
  • Because the resolution failed, the study it proposed was not required to happen.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1557311

    Passed100 members voted

    (H) 3rd Reading Passed

    FOR · 92AGAINST · 8

    92For

    • Republican52
    • Democratic40

    8Against

    • Republican8
  2. Division No. 1555460

    Passed100 members voted

    (H) 2nd Reading Passed

    FOR · 89AGAINST · 11

    89For

    • Republican53
    • Democratic36

    11Against

    • Republican7
    • Democratic4
  3. Division No. 1550020

    Passed14 members voted

    (H) Energy, Technology and Federal Relations--Do Pass

    FOR · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    14For

    • Republican8
    • Democratic6

    0Against