Hospitals face fee tied to property tax liability

Summary#

SB 560, titled “Provide for a hospital community benefit fee,” amends Montana laws and creates new reporting rules, a fee, and a state special revenue account. Its stated goal is to link nonprofit hospitals’ reported community benefits to the property taxes they would otherwise owe, and to direct fee revenue to certain critical access hospitals. The act takes effect January 1, 2027, but its application dates create an unresolved conflict about which hospitals are covered.

  • Nonprofit hospitals must report community-benefit spending to the Department of Public Health and Human Services (DPHHS), including how some spending relates to needs identified in their community health needs assessments.
  • A nonprofit hospital’s annual community benefit must exceed its prior-year potential property-tax liability. If it does not, DPHHS must charge a fee equal to the shortfall.
  • The Department of Revenue must estimate that liability using the hospital’s real property, treating it as commercial property for the calculation. Property already taxed is excluded.
  • Fee revenue goes into a new state account. DPHHS must use it to fund each critical access hospital that is not affiliated with another hospital, based on the number of beds.
  • The bill also amends existing hospital-policy law. It includes requirements for written financial-assistance and community-benefit policies, but the supplied material does not show which of these requirements are new.

What it means for you#

  • Nonprofit hospitals: They would have reporting duties and could owe a fee if their reported community benefit does not exceed the calculated property-tax liability. The bill counts specified Schedule H expenses, bad debt, and Medicare shortfall amounts in the calculation.
  • Critical access hospitals: The account is meant to provide funding to those not affiliated with another hospital. The bill says reporting provisions apply to critical access hospitals starting in 2027 and sections 2–6 apply to them starting in 2031. But the operative provisions refer to “nonprofit hospitals,” and the bill’s definition of “hospital” excludes critical access hospitals. It is therefore unclear how these provisions apply to them.
  • Patients: The bill does not directly change eligibility for care or set new patient benefits. It includes written-policy requirements about financial assistance and discrimination based on ability to pay; the supplied text does not establish how much those requirements change current law.
  • Taxpayers: This is a state fee calculated using a hospital’s potential property-tax liability, not a change to property-tax rates or an order to pay property tax.

Money#

No publicly available information on the total public cost or the amount of fees expected.

  • Hospitals below the required community-benefit level would pay a fee equal to the gap.
  • Fee receipts would fund eligible critical access hospitals, distributed based on beds. The bill does not provide a separate appropriation or estimate how much the account would receive.
  • DPHHS and the Department of Revenue would have reporting, calculation, rulemaking, and funding duties. No staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s definition excludes critical access hospitals from “hospital,” while its applicability dates say the new provisions apply to critical access hospitals. The text does not clearly resolve this conflict.
  • It is unclear how DPHHS will decide what counts as community benefit in practice beyond the listed Schedule H amounts, or how it will apply the reporting rules.
  • The bill requires rules for disputing property values, but does not set out the dispute process or say whether hospitals can appeal the final fee.
  • It does not specify how the per-bed funding is calculated beyond saying it is based on beds, or how funding would be divided if fee revenue is limited.
  • The supplied material does not include the pre-bill text of the amended laws, so it is not possible to verify which reporting or hospital-policy duties are new.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address a gap between nonprofit hospitals’ community-benefit spending and the property taxes they would otherwise owe.
  • A possible argument for the fee is that it turns any shortfall into funding for critical access hospitals that are not affiliated with another hospital.
  • Using reported Schedule H amounts and property-tax estimates gives the state a stated basis for comparing the two amounts.
  • The bill requires the Department of Revenue to exclude property on which a nonprofit hospital already pays property taxes.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the fee’s calculation may not match the value of direct community services: it counts bad debt and Medicare shortfalls as well as other listed expenses.
  • The bill does not clearly explain how its nonprofit-hospital rules apply to critical access hospitals, even though it sets dates for applying provisions to them.
  • The funding formula and expected revenue are not specified, so eligible hospitals cannot tell from the bill how much support they would receive.
  • The bill assigns new duties to two departments without estimating the staffing or administrative costs.

Votes

5 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1560651

    Passed50 members voted

    (S) 3rd Reading Passed as Amended by House

    FOR · 50

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    50For

    • Republican32
    • Democratic18

    0Against

  2. Division No. 1559421

    Passed49 members voted

    (S) 2nd Reading House Amendments Concurred

    FOR · 49

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Republican31
    • Democratic18

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1537842

    Passed48 members voted

    (S) 3rd Reading Passed

    FOR · 30AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    30For

    • Republican30

    18Against

    • Democratic18

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  4. Division No. 1537365

    Passed48 members voted

    (S) 2nd Reading Passed

    FOR · 31AGAINST · 17

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    31For

    • Republican30
    • Democratic1

    17Against

    • Democratic17

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  5. Division No. 1534900

    Passed11 members voted

    (S) Public Health, Welfare and Safety--Do Pass

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican7

    4Against

    • Democratic4