Lodging taxes fund principal residence tax relief

Summary#

HB 946, titled “Revise selective sales taxes to provide ongoing property tax relief,” failed and is not law. It would amend Montana tax and property-tax laws and create a state-funded property tax credit for some principal residences; its stated goal is ongoing property tax relief.

  • For tax year 2025, eligible owners could claim a one-time credit of up to $400 for property taxes paid for 2024.
  • Starting in 2026, the Department of Revenue would certify eligible principal residences, and counties would put state-funded credits on their property tax bills.
  • The ongoing credit would be funded from lodging and rental car tax revenue. The department would calculate it per certified residence using half of the account balance after specified set-asides.
  • The bill would increase lodging and rental car taxes, but the supplied text does not include the sections showing the new rates.
  • False claims could bring criminal prosecution and recovery of the credit. For the 2025 credit, the bill also provides for a penalty of 300% of the credit and 12% annual interest.

What it means for you#

  • Owners applying for the 2025 credit: The proposed credit was the lesser of $400 or the eligible 2024 property taxes paid. Applicants would have had to apply by August 15, 2025, and have a principal residence in 2025. The bill’s deadline has passed; in any case, the bill failed.
  • Principal-residence owners from 2026: To qualify, an owner would generally need to own and live in the home for at least seven months of the year, pay its property taxes, and have only one principal residence. The home’s value could not exceed 4.5 times the statewide median residential value. Entity-owned homes would generally be excluded, with an exception for certain revocable trusts.
  • Lodging and rental car customers and businesses: The bill proposes higher taxes on lodging and rental cars. The supplied text does not show the rates or who would have the legal duty to collect and remit them.
  • The Department of Revenue and counties: The department would handle applications, certification and funding distributions; counties would apply credits to property tax bills. The bill creates an account, not a new independent agency.
  • Other property tax help: The proposed credits would not prevent an owner from receiving assistance under another property tax assistance program.

Money#

The bill would direct lodging and rental car tax revenue to property tax assistance, but the available text gives no estimate of total public cost or tax revenue.

  • For ongoing assistance, the department could retain up to $1.5 million each fiscal year for certification administration and would retain $100,000 for successful appeals. Half of the remaining account balance would be divided among certified residences.
  • The bill provides statutory authority to pay credits and related administration costs from the account, but does not give a total cost estimate.
  • The exact proposed tax increases are not in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text is incomplete. It does not show the proposed lodging and rental car tax rates or all rules for allocating that revenue.
  • The materials do not explain what would happen to the half of the remaining account balance not used in the per-residence calculation.
  • The bill does not specify how the value limit would be measured, or how large the ongoing credit would be for an individual owner.
  • The Department of Revenue could require additional eligibility information, but the bill does not set out all application rules or processing timelines.
  • The parent laws being amended were not supplied, so the available material does not establish what parts of the bill would be new compared with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to return some lodging and rental car tax revenue to owners of qualifying principal residences as property tax credits.
  • A possible argument for the method is that it links the assistance to a defined revenue source and sends it through property tax bills.
  • The seven-month residence rule and one-home limit would focus assistance on qualifying principal residences rather than all property.
  • The bill would allow eligible owners to receive this assistance alongside other property tax assistance.

Case against#

  • One concern is that increasing lodging and rental car taxes could raise costs for people using those services; the supplied text does not show the size of the increases.
  • Because the ongoing credit depends on available revenue and the number of certified homes, owners would not know from the bill alone how much relief they would receive.
  • The application and certification system would require administrative work, but the bill does not provide a full cost estimate or detailed processing rules.
  • The value cap and exclusion of most entity-owned homes would leave some properties outside the program, while the bill does not explain the policy basis for those limits.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1534815

    Passed21 members voted

    (H) Taxation--To Table

    FOR · 19AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    19For

    • Republican11
    • Democratic8

    2Against

    • Republican2