PSC would shift to two elected, three appointed

Summary#

SB 561, “Revise public service commission membership,” would amend four sections of Montana law and add rules for selecting commissioners. It would change the Public Service Commission from five elected members to two elected members and three appointed members. Its stated goal is to revise how commissioners are selected. The bill failed and did not become law.

  • The governor would appoint three commissioners, subject to confirmation by at least two-thirds of the Senate. Two commissioners would remain elected.
  • The two elected seats would be tied to two districts based on congressional districts. The bill would set six-year terms for both elected and appointed commissioners.
  • Appointed commissioners would need relevant experience, four years of separation from professional ties to regulated entities, and no financial interests in those entities for themselves, their spouses, or minor children.
  • The governor would appoint replacements for appointed commissioners, with Senate confirmation. A vacancy in an elected seat would be filled by appointment until the next general election.
  • The bill would take effect on passage and approval. It includes a transition schedule for filling appointed seats as current commissioners’ terms end.

What it means for you#

  • Montana voters: You would elect two commissioners instead of five. The other three would be appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Senate.
  • Commissioner candidates: Appointed candidates would have to document their qualifications and pay a $100 filing fee. The bill’s separate section on elected commissioners contains wording that refers to “appointed” commissioners in some qualifications, so it is unclear which requirements it intends to impose on elected candidates.
  • Governor and Senate: The governor would select appointed commissioners and check their qualifications before announcing nominations. The Senate would confirm them by a two-thirds vote, and the bill says it may reject an appointment for reasons beyond the listed criteria.
  • Regulated companies and the public: The bill changes the commission’s membership and selection rules, not its authority over regulated services. It does not create a new public application or review process.
  • Current law comparison: The supplied text appears to change a five-member, elected commission to a mix of elected and appointed members. The parent Act was not supplied, so the current statutory wording and the full extent of the changes could not be verified.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated public cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require a $100 filing fee from an appointed commissioner candidate who files qualification documents.
  • It would create three appointed commissioner positions, but provides no salary, staffing, or operating-cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s text contains conflicting wording about the number of districts: it changes “five” to “two” but also retains a list of five districts.
  • The qualifications section for elected commissioners refers to appointed commissioners for financial-interest, citizenship, and residency rules. The text does not clearly state whether those rules apply to elected commissioners.
  • The bill sets six-year terms and a 12-years-in-24-years limit for elected commissioners, but also retains wording that bars certification after eight years in a 16-year period. How those limits would work together is unclear.
  • The bill does not provide salary or operating-cost details, or explain how the two districts would be mapped if congressional districts changed.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so overlap with existing rules cannot be fully checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a mixed commission could combine voter-selected members with appointed members chosen for relevant technical or professional experience.
  • The separation period and financial-interest restrictions are intended to limit direct ties between appointed commissioners and the companies they regulate.
  • Senate confirmation would add a check on the governor’s appointments.

Case against#

  • One concern is that three of five commissioners would be appointed rather than elected, reducing voters’ direct role in choosing the commission’s membership.
  • The bill allows the Senate to reject nominees for reasons beyond the listed criteria, without stating what those additional criteria are.
  • Conflicting district and qualification wording could make it hard to apply the new rules consistently.
  • The bill does not say how the added appointment process would be staffed or funded.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1537701

    Passed48 members voted

    (S) 3rd Reading Passed

    FOR · 34AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    34For

    • Democratic17
    • Republican17

    14Against

    • Republican13
    • Democratic1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1537462

    Defeated50 members voted

    (S) 2nd Reading Motion to Amend Failed

    AGAINST · 32FOR · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    32Against

    • Democratic17
    • Republican15

    18For

    • Republican17
    • Democratic1
  3. Division No. 1537463

    Passed50 members voted

    (S) 2nd Reading Passed

    FOR · 32AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    32For

    • Democratic17
    • Republican15

    18Against

    • Republican17
    • Democratic1
  4. Division No. 1533847

    Passed13 members voted

    (S) Energy, Technology & Federal Relations--Do Pass

    FOR · 9AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    9For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic4

    4Against

    • Republican3
    • Democratic1