Water permits: review could overturn cancellations

Summary#

SB-11 would amend Nevada Revised Statutes section 533.395, which governs cancellation of permits to appropriate public water. Its stated goal is to revise the cancellation process; it is prefiled and is not law.

  • A permit holder whose permit is cancelled could still petition the State Engineer for review within 60 days after notice of cancellation.
  • The State Engineer could rescind a cancellation without a public hearing. In that case, the permit’s effective date would not be vacated.
  • If the State Engineer changes or rescinds a cancellation after a hearing, the effective date may be vacated and replaced by the petition filing date. The Engineer must consider the permit’s procedural history, whether diversion works had begun, and whether water had been put to beneficial use before notice of cancellation. This list is not exhaustive.
  • The bill keeps the rule that permit cancellations cannot be taken to court unless a petition for review has been filed and the cancellation has been affirmed, modified, or rescinded.

What it means for you#

  • Permit holders: If your permit is cancelled under the provisions covered by this section, you would have no later than 60 days after the notice to petition the State Engineer. The bill does not change the requirement to show good faith and reasonable diligence in perfecting an appropriation.
  • Permit holders seeking review: The State Engineer could rescind a cancellation without a hearing. If that happens, the permit’s effective date stays in place. After a hearing, the Engineer could decide whether to change the effective date, considering the listed factors and others.
  • State Engineer: The Engineer would have authority to rescind a cancellation without a hearing and, after a hearing, would have to consider the listed factors when deciding whether to change the effective date.
  • Other water users and the public: The bill does not directly change water-use rights, create new permits, or change water allocations. A permit’s effective date can matter to its standing, but the bill does not say how any date change would affect other permits.
  • The supplied bill digest describes current law, but the current version of NRS 533.395 was not separately provided, so I could not independently verify that comparison.

Money#

The fiscal note says the bill would have no effect on state or local government budgets or the State Highway Fund.

  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate or detail any staffing needs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set criteria for when the Engineer may rescind a cancellation without a hearing.
  • It does not explain how the Engineer would weigh the required factors when deciding whether to change an effective date.
  • It does not set a decision deadline or add appeal steps beyond the existing court-review condition.
  • The bill does not explain how changes to a permit’s effective date could affect other water users or permits.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the Engineer could correct a cancellation without requiring a public hearing.
  • Keeping the effective date when a cancellation is rescinded without a hearing could avoid changing that date just because the permit was cancelled.
  • Considering the permit’s history, construction, and beneficial use could let the Engineer account for the specific circumstances before changing an effective date.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill allows cancellation to be rescinded without a hearing but does not state when that option should be used.
  • The Engineer’s decision about changing an effective date would involve discretion, and the required factors are not an exhaustive list.
  • The bill does not explain how a changed effective date could affect other permits or water users.