Municipal code enforcement tightened

Summary#

HB 244, “Updating and recodifying the municipal enforcement of the building and fire code,” amends several New Hampshire laws, mainly RSA 155-A. It reorganizes rules for local building-code enforcement and adds permit deadlines, appeal procedures and enforcement tools. Its stated goal is to update and recodify municipal enforcement; that goal does not guarantee particular results. The supplied status says it was signed into law, but gives no start date.

  • Local governments may establish a local enforcement agency. The state building code applies statewide, and local changes are limited to those allowed by law.
  • Building officials must adopt minimum application requirements and decide completed building-permit applications within 30 days, or within 60 days for nonresidential applications and residential applications covering more than 10 units.
  • The law sets out local building-code appeal boards and gives the state building code review board a role in appeals. Appeal boards cannot waive state code requirements.
  • Local officials may use court actions, cease-and-desist orders and fines to enforce code requirements. Violations can bring daily civil penalties and criminal charges.
  • The text also addresses sprinkler requirements for certain homes, local restrictions on energy systems, and when municipalities may issue permits despite unfinished streets or utilities.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal governments: They may establish local enforcement agencies and can provide appeal boards with staff, consultants and funding. The bill lays out how some local code changes must be proposed and adopted.
  • Builders and permit applicants: A building official must decide a completed application within the specified 30- or 60-day period. A permit cannot be denied solely because streets or utilities are unfinished if approved security has been provided; however, occupancy may still be barred until required work is complete, unless the planning board allows otherwise.
  • Property owners, tenants and others affected by enforcement: Officials may seek court orders or issue cease-and-desist orders for violations. Depending on the order, activity may have to stop immediately. The text provides for service on owners, tenants and others, and gives recipients 20 days to answer a cease-and-desist order in court.
  • People appealing a building-code decision: The text provides for local appeals and further appeals to the state review board. It also says an appeal can pause some permits or enforcement actions, subject to a danger exception.
  • Homeowners and energy customers: The recodified text bars local requirements for automatic sprinklers in specified residential situations and bars local rules restricting a person’s choice of a safe, commercially available heating or other energy system or provider. The supplied materials do not establish how much of these provisions changes prior law.
  • Municipal taxpayers and people subject to enforcement: A municipality that wins an enforcement case may recover its actual costs and reasonable legal fees. Courts may also order repayment of some public costs. Unpaid costs of corrective work can become a lien on the property.

Money#

No publicly available information on the law’s total public cost or expected revenue.

  • Local governments may fund appeal-board staff, consultants, equipment and other work; the text gives no staffing requirement or cost estimate.
  • Appeal boards may charge certain costs to applicants. City and town fees must be publicly posted; an unpublished fee is waived for that application.
  • The text sets civil penalties of $275 for a first offense and $550 for later offenses, per day of continuing violation after conviction or written notice, whichever comes first. It also provides for criminal charges.
  • Municipalities may recover costs and reasonable legal fees if they prevail in enforcement cases. The text does not estimate collections or expenses.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends partway through an amendment and does not include the complete enacted law or the current versions of the laws being amended. I could not verify against current law which provisions are new and which mainly restate existing rules.
  • The text gives more than one route for appeals, including differing references to local boards and state review. The full enacted text is needed to confirm how those routes fit together.
  • The supplied materials do not give an effective date or explain any transition for pending permit applications or enforcement cases.
  • The bill does not set a single required staffing level or provide an overall cost estimate for municipalities.
  • The complete procedures for applying for permits, including all required documents and any further decision rules, are not fully shown in the supplied excerpt.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it puts municipal enforcement rules and related procedures into one main law, making them easier to find and use.
  • Permit decision deadlines could make the timing of decisions clearer for applicants and local officials.
  • Written appeal decisions, public records and stated appeal procedures could make disputes easier to review.
  • Court enforcement, daily penalties and recovery of public costs could give municipalities tools to address ongoing violations.

Case against#

  • The text gives municipalities significant enforcement tools, including stop-work orders, daily fines, criminal charges and property liens. Mistakes or disputes could therefore have serious consequences for affected people.
  • The supplied text contains different descriptions of appeal routes and does not clearly resolve how they work together.
  • Municipalities may face new or increased costs for staffing, consultants and enforcement, but no estimate or funding plan is provided.
  • Because the prior law and complete enacted text are not supplied, readers cannot tell from these materials how much the bill changes existing rules or how all its provisions interact.