Blockchain law shields miners and wallets

Summary#

HB 639, the Blockchain Basic Laws, creates a new chapter of New Hampshire law and amends the law on Superior Court procedure. Its stated goal is to encourage blockchain business and innovation while protecting investors and consumers.

  • State and local agencies may not block people from using digital assets to buy legal goods or services, keeping them in wallets they control, or paying with them. They also may not impose a charge solely because a digital asset was used as the payment method.
  • The law protects operating blockchain nodes and participating in staking from certain licensing and securities-law requirements. It also exempts home mining and digital-asset mining businesses from the state money-transmitter license requirement.
  • A person staking only their own assets is not treated as offering or selling a security under the state securities law. An exchange offering staking as a service receives the same treatment if the assets stay under the exchange’s control or remain under the owner’s control. The Secretary of State may still act against false claims about staking services.
  • A person directly affected by a violation may seek court relief, including an order to stop or remedy it. A person who proves a purposeful violation and wins may receive reasonable attorney’s fees.
  • The Supreme Court may establish a blockchain dispute docket in Superior Court. Parties must consent to its jurisdiction; a governor-appointed presiding justice and other designated judges would hear qualifying cases.

What it means for you#

  • Digital-asset users: State and local government agencies may not prohibit the listed uses or charge you solely for using a digital asset to pay. This is not a general exemption from taxes or fees.
  • Miners and node operators: The law protects the listed activities from government bans and exempts home mining, mining businesses, and node operation from the money-transmitter license requirement. The bill does not set operating rules for these activities.
  • People and businesses that stake assets: The stated securities-law exemptions apply only under the bill’s conditions. The bill does not remove the Secretary of State’s power to pursue a person or exchange that falsely claims to offer qualifying staking.
  • People in blockchain disputes: You may seek relief if directly affected by a violation. The new docket is not automatic: the Supreme Court must establish it, and parties must consent to its jurisdiction.
  • Investors and consumers: The bill’s purpose includes protecting them, but it does not set out a new complaint, investigation, or restitution process. The fiscal note says the Bureau of Securities would lose authority over some mining and staking services.

Money#

The state fiscal impact is indeterminable; the bill provides no funding and authorizes no new positions.

  • The Judicial Branch estimates added costs below $10,000 unless a new judge is appointed rather than assigned from the current judges. A new judge would cost about $350,000 a year.
  • The fiscal note says the Bureau of Securities could spend less on investigations, but lost fines and penalties would offset those savings, for an expected neutral effect.
  • The number of added civil cases, and any related costs or revenue changes, cannot be estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The Supreme Court may establish the docket, but the bill does not say when it will do so. It is also unclear how the requirement for party consent works alongside the direction that certain civil cases “shall be assigned” to the docket.
  • The bill does not define “complex disputes” or explain how a case qualifies as involving blockchain technology.
  • The fiscal note says it is unclear whether existing contract law governs smart contracts and which court would have exclusive jurisdiction over certain cryptocurrency trusts. The bill also does not directly address the existing law on fiduciary access to digital assets.
  • The parent statutes’ prior text was not supplied, so the full change from current law cannot be independently checked. The fiscal note says the bill limits the Bureau of Securities’ authority over mining and staking services, including its ability to seek investor restitution or impose fines and penalties; it says no other state law-enforcement body would receive that authority.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give users and businesses clearer protections against state and local restrictions on specified blockchain activities.
  • A possible argument for the licensing and securities-law limits is that people using their own assets for mining or staking should not be treated like businesses transmitting other people’s money or selling securities.
  • A specialist court docket could give parties and judges a place to hear technically complex disputes.
  • The law allows court relief for violations and attorney’s fees for people who prove a purposeful violation, providing a way to enforce its protections.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the securities-law exemptions could reduce protection for investors using mining or staking services. The fiscal note says the Bureau of Securities would lose power to seek restitution and impose fines or penalties in these cases.
  • It is unclear how the new protections fit with other state laws and existing court processes. That uncertainty could lead to more litigation and added public costs.
  • The docket’s scope, party-consent requirement, and appointment of a presiding justice may require further decisions before the process is clear.