A study and report on the feasibility of permitting motorists to make a right turn at a red signal on Staten Island

Summary#

Introduction 0324-2026, sponsored by Council Member Frank Morano, would create a local law requiring the New York City Department of Transportation (DOT) to study whether motorists should be allowed to turn right at red signals on Staten Island after stopping fully. Its stated purpose is to assess the feasibility and effects of that permission; the bill would not itself allow the turns. It was introduced and referred to committee on January 29, 2026, and is waiting in that committee.

  • The DOT Commissioner must consult Staten Island community boards, the Department of Environmental Protection, and the Police Department.
  • The study must assess crash rates, sight distance, large vehicles’ turning space, safety near schools and older adult centers and at high-priority intersections, congestion, environmental effects, and whether drivers are likely to stop fully.
  • The Commissioner must identify intersections where right turns on red are already permitted, and intersections where they could be permitted, grouped by community district.
  • The Commissioner must send an update to the Mayor and Council Speaker within six months, then send and post a final report within one year. If the Commissioner finds the permission feasible, the report must recommend how to implement it; if not, it must explain why and include a map identifying intersections.

What it means for you#

  • Motorists and other street users: The bill would not change where right turns on red are allowed. Any change would require further action after the study.
  • Staten Island residents: The required report would address safety, traffic, and environmental effects and identify potential intersections. The bill does not require the city to adopt its recommendations.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • DOT must carry out the study and prepare the update and report, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill lists factors for the study but does not set numerical standards for deciding whether a turn is feasible.
  • It does not require the city to act on the report or set a process for deciding whether to permit turns at particular intersections.

Case for#

  • The required study could give the city information about safety, congestion, and environmental effects before any decision to permit turns.
  • Requiring recommendations only if the Commissioner finds the change feasible could help connect that finding to possible implementation steps, such as signs, driver education, and enforcement.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires a broad study but sets no method or thresholds for weighing its factors, leaving important judgments to the Commissioner.
  • The bill requires research and reporting but does not require a later decision or action, so it may not resolve whether any turns will be permitted.