Summary#
Introduction 0385-2026, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, would amend the New York City Administrative Code and the city’s Human Rights Law. It is in committee and is not law. Its stated goal is to prohibit discrimination in issuing credit and improve borrowers’ understanding of how credit terms are set.
- Creditors could not discriminate in granting, withholding, extending or renewing credit, or setting its rates, terms or conditions, based on the listed protected characteristics or a person’s lawful source of income or whether children live with them.
- The bill allows credit decisions based on factually supportable, objective differences in creditworthiness, but bars using aggregate statistics or assumptions about the listed characteristics, income sources or children.
- A creditor would have to disclose how it calculated a credit decision or terms if an applicant asks in writing. The bill does not require automatic disclosure to every potential borrower.
- The Commission on Human Rights would have to conduct outreach and education, and carry out at least five credit-discrimination investigations using pairs of testers over a one-year period. It would refer detected incidents to its law enforcement bureau and report investigation results to the Council Speaker.
What it means for you#
- Credit applicants: The proposed protections cover race, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, age, gender, marital status, disability, partnership and caregiver status, uniformed service, alienage or citizenship status, lawful source of income, and whether children live with the applicant. The bill permits consideration of age when it has a demonstrable and statistically sound relationship to creditworthiness; the age rules do not apply to people under 18. Creditors may still ask about marital history or status and number of dependents.
- Creditors: They would have to follow these rules and, on an applicant’s written request, disclose how decisions and credit terms were calculated.
- Commission on Human Rights: It would have to conduct outreach and education and investigate credit discrimination. The bill does not set out an application or complaint process for borrowers.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The bill requires Commission outreach and at least five investigations, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- The investigation provisions refer to work starting by January 1, 2023, and a report due by January 1, 2024—dates that have passed. The bill does not explain how those dates would apply if it became law.
- The bill requires at least five investigations “for a period of one year,” but does not say when that one-year period would begin.
- The supplied materials do not include the current Human Rights Law text, so it is not possible to verify which of these protections would be new or how they would interact with existing rules.
- The bill does not specify how quickly creditors must answer a written request for their calculation method.
Case for#
- The bill’s stated purpose is to address discrimination in credit decisions. Its protections cover both the decision to provide credit and the rates, terms and conditions offered.
- A possible argument for the written-request rule is that it could help applicants understand how a creditor reached a decision or set terms.
- Matched-pair testing could help the Commission identify differences in how creditors treat applicants with similar credentials.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill requires investigations and outreach without providing a cost estimate or specifying the staff needed.
- The bill sets no deadline for creditors to answer written requests, which could limit how useful the disclosure is to applicants.
- The investigation and reporting dates appear to be outdated, leaving unclear how the required work and report would be timed.