Prohibiting surveillance pricing

Summary#

Introduction 0891-A, sponsored by Council Member Julie Menin, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. The Council passed it on November 12, 2026, and sent it to the Mayor; it is not yet law. Its stated goal is to prohibit “surveillance pricing.”

  • It would bar businesses and service providers from using an algorithm and personal data to set different prices for different customers for the same goods or services, subject to listed exceptions and discount rules.
  • It would also bar using or disclosing personal data to facilitate that pricing, and advertising or promoting prices set that way.
  • The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) would enforce the law. The city’s Corporation Counsel could investigate and use subpoenas in connection with court proceedings.
  • A covered business—a business with fewer than 15 locations nationally that does most of its business at physical locations in New York City—would get notice and 30 days to correct a first violation before DCWP brought a proceeding.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If a business uses surveillance pricing or offers a bona fide custom discount, it must have reasonable procedures for you to request and receive information about what personal data it considers and how it uses that data to set prices. The bill does not set a response deadline.
  • Businesses and service providers: They could not set or adjust a reference or consumer price using surveillance pricing, promote such a price, or handle personal data for the purpose of facilitating it. A reference price is the public price offered for a reasonably substantial and recent period; a consumer price adjusts that price for discounts.
  • Businesses offering discounts: The bill permits ordinary, generally available discounts. It also allows specified custom discounts, including some for loyalty-program members, people who identify themselves as belonging to a defined group, and customers’ purchase histories. These discounts must meet conditions on disclosure and use of data, and must be offered uniformly to consumers who meet the disclosed criteria. Online marketplaces have separate, detailed rules for some purchase-history and delivery-fee discounts.
  • Certain pricing is outside the ban: Listed exceptions include insurance-related activity, some creditworthiness-based pricing, and pricing required or expressly authorized by law. Securities brokers and registered investment advisers are also excluded from the definition of surveillance pricing in the stated circumstances.
  • Enforcement: The maximum civil penalty is $1,000 per violation. Each consumer or transaction counts separately. Court proceedings may also seek actual damages, restitution, injunctions, and other relief. A first-time covered business may avoid a proceeding for a violation it corrects within 30 days, including by providing restitution to harmed consumers.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires covered entities to maintain procedures and provide relevant data to DCWP electronically upon request, but gives no estimate of compliance or agency costs.
  • Civil penalties may be up to $1,000 per violation, with each consumer or transaction treated as a separate violation. Other remedies can include restitution and actual damages.
  • If enacted, the law would take effect one year after it becomes law.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set deadlines or a detailed process for consumers’ data requests.
  • It calls for DCWP rules on some data access procedures, but those rules are not included here.
  • The terms “reasonably substantial and recent period” and “reasonable procedures” may require interpretation in practice.
  • The material gives no estimate of how many businesses or transactions would be affected, or of enforcement and compliance costs.
  • The Mayor’s action after the bill was sent is not given. Its start date depends on becoming law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would limit using personal data to charge different customers different prices for the same goods or services.
  • Requiring information-request procedures and making relevant data available to DCWP could help consumers and the department understand how covered pricing decisions are made.
  • The bill preserves many general discounts and allows defined custom discounts, which could limit disruption to promotions and loyalty programs.

Case against#

  • One concern is that businesses may find the boundary between prohibited pricing and allowed custom discounts difficult to apply, especially where the rules differ for online marketplaces.
  • The bill requires procedures and electronic access to personal data, but does not set consumer response deadlines or spell out all implementation details.
  • Penalties can apply separately to each consumer or transaction, so total penalties could be substantial; the available material does not estimate likely enforcement or compliance costs.