Requiring the department of investigation to investigate allegations of evidentiary misconduct by police officers

Summary#

Int. 0651-2026 is a proposed local law sponsored by Council Member Lincoln Restler. It would add a section to the New York City Charter and a section to the Administrative Code, requiring the Department of Investigation (DOI) to investigate complaints of police officers’ evidentiary misconduct. Its stated goal is to address conduct that impugns the integrity of criminal court proceedings. It was introduced and referred to committee on February 12, 2026; it is not law and is waiting in committee.

  • DOI would have to create an online complaint referral system within 180 days and keep it running. It must coordinate with the Office of Criminal Justice to notify defense organizations, district attorneys, court staff and other interested parties about how to file complaints.
  • “Evidentiary misconduct” includes, among other things, misleading testimony, withholding relevant exculpatory evidence, failures involving body-worn cameras or disclosure of evidence, and identification procedures likely to undermine reliability.
  • DOI would have to investigate each complaint by reviewing relevant materials provided, available court records and relevant information held by the Police Department. It may interview the officer. It must notify relevant interested parties of its decision.
  • For substantiated complaints, DOI would have to assess whether the misconduct was knowing or intentional. Depending on that finding, it must investigate possible patterns, publish and share a report, or send a report to the Police Department’s Internal Affairs Bureau for further investigation and a recommendation about retraining or discipline. Criminal offenses must be referred to the appropriate district attorney.
  • The Police Department would have to provide requested information, documents and relevant body-worn camera footage within 7 business days, and make relevant employees available for questioning. DOI would have to publish specified annual complaint statistics and information about certain cases.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in criminal cases: A defendant, prosecutor, attorney, judge, court attorney, police officer or other person with evidence of misconduct could make a complaint through the proposed system. The bill does not say that filing a complaint changes a case’s outcome.
  • Police officers: DOI could investigate allegations about their conduct. The bill does not itself impose discipline; for certain cases, DOI would send a report to the Police Department’s Internal Affairs Bureau for further investigation and a recommendation.
  • The Police Department: It would have to meet DOI’s 7-business-day requests and make relevant employees available for questioning.
  • The public: DOI would have to publish annual reports with complaint counts and other required information. Some published case details are limited by what the bill says may be disclosed under law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • DOI would have to set up and maintain the referral system, investigate complaints and publish reports, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • The Police Department would have to provide records and make employees available. No estimate of those costs is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “impugns the integrity” or explain how DOI would decide what counts as a full investigation.
  • It sets no deadline for completing an investigation or deciding whether to substantiate a complaint, and does not describe an appeal or review process.
  • It does not explain what notice or opportunity to respond an officer would receive, or how complaint and investigation information would be protected.
  • The source does not include the current Charter or Administrative Code text, so existing complaint procedures, DOI powers and overlap with current rules could not be verified.
  • The bill does not specify how the Police Department’s Internal Affairs Bureau must act after receiving a report.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to create a route for people with evidence of misconduct to bring it to DOI, rather than leaving the complaint process unspecified in this legislation.
  • Requiring review of court records, police information and other relevant materials could help DOI assess allegations using more than one source of evidence.
  • Separating cases where DOI finds evidence of knowing or intentional misconduct from cases where it does not could support different follow-up steps and public reporting.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires DOI to investigate complaints but leaves key terms and investigation timelines open, so the process could be applied unevenly or take an unknown amount of time.
  • The bill requires substantial record review and reporting but does not provide a cost estimate or specify resources for that work.
  • For some substantiated cases, further investigation and recommendations would go to the Police Department’s Internal Affairs Bureau; the bill does not set out what that Bureau must do or require a particular outcome.