Reporting on police department compliance with freedom of information law requests

Summary#

Introduction 0718-2026, sponsored by Council Member Yusef Salaam, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require the Department of Investigation (DOI) commissioner to publish an annual report on NYPD Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests. The bill’s stated goal is to provide data, analysis and recommendations about NYPD compliance; it is still in committee and is not law.

  • The report would list each unique FOIL request, with its topic and specified dates about the request, response, extensions, decision and any appeal.
  • The report would also include a qualitative analysis, recommendations for faster NYPD compliance, and a data dictionary (an explanation of the data).
  • DOI must send the report to the Mayor and Council Speaker and post it on the department’s website.
  • Reports must not contain personally identifiable information, except where the bill expressly provides otherwise.
  • The bill says it takes effect immediately. Its first reporting deadline is no later than January 1, 2026.

What it means for you#

  • People who make NYPD FOIL requests: The bill would make information about requests and response timelines publicly reportable. It does not change how to file a request or require the NYPD to grant one.
  • NYPD: It would be the subject of the reports and of recommendations, but the bill does not impose a new response deadline on the NYPD.
  • DOI: Its commissioner would have to prepare and publish the annual report.
  • Current law: The bill text supplied does not include the existing Administrative Code, so I could not verify whether related reporting duties already exist. The bill itself does not change the underlying FOIL request process.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost.

  • The bill requires DOI to prepare, send and post annual reports, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The January 1, 2026 first deadline falls before the bill’s introduction on February 24, 2026. The bill gives no later first-report date if it becomes law after that deadline.
  • It does not say how DOI must obtain or check the request-level data.
  • It bars personally identifiable information but does not explain how DOI should handle information that could identify someone indirectly.
  • The bill does not set a format or process for making corrections to a report.

Case for#

  • The bill’s design could let the public see how long NYPD takes to respond, how often it requests extensions, and what happens on appeal.
  • Requiring analysis and recommendations could help identify ways for NYPD to comply more quickly. The bill does not guarantee that changes will follow.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires detailed, request-by-request reporting but gives no estimate of the work or cost involved.
  • The privacy rule may not settle how to protect requesters when a topic or other details could identify them.
  • The first report deadline is already past as written, and the bill does not explain how that deadline would work if the law takes effect later.