Summary#
Int. 594, sponsored by Council Member Crystal Hudson, would amend the New York City Administrative Code on illegal curb cuts and curb-cut permit applications. It is intended to address illegal curb cuts and give community boards a chance to comment on applications. It has been referred to a committee and is not law; the supplied history does not name the committee.
- The Department of Transportation (DOT) must investigate each complaint of an illegal curb cut within 30 days. If it finds the curb cut was made without required permits, DOT must paint it green within three days and order the property owner to fix it or obtain permits and final sign-off within 30 days.
- If the violation is not corrected, it continues until DOT is satisfied. Within six months after DOT becomes aware of an illegal curb cut, DOT must restore the curb unless the owner fixes it or obtains the required permits and sign-off.
- DOT must recover the restoration cost from the owner of property that benefited from the illegal curb cut, the person who created it, or both. Cost recovery is in addition to any civil penalty.
- For each new curb-cut permit application, DOT must notify the community board within seven days. The board has 60 days to comment; DOT must consider its comments and inspect the proposed location before issuing a permit.
What it means for you#
- Property owners and people who create illegal curb cuts: DOT must order the owner to correct the violation within 30 days. If it is not corrected, the violation continues. DOT must restore the curb within six months unless the owner fixes it or gets the required permits and sign-off. The owner, the person who created the curb cut, or both may have to pay DOT’s restoration costs.
- People applying for a curb-cut permit: The community board for the area must be notified and may send comments and recommendations. DOT must consider them and inspect the proposed location before deciding whether to issue a permit.
- Community boards: They get 60 days from notification to submit comments and recommendations, but the bill does not require DOT to follow them.
- DOT: It must meet the investigation, notice, inspection, marking, restoration, and cost-recovery requirements. The bill would take effect 90 days after it becomes law.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated city costs or savings is included in the supplied material.
- DOT would have to carry out investigations, inspections, notifications, and curb restoration; the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- DOT must recover restoration costs from the owner who benefited, the person who created the curb cut, or both. The bill also refers to civil penalties but does not state an amount in the supplied text.
What is unclear#
- The supplied text defines “curb cut,” but does not set out how DOT would decide whether a curb cut is illegal or how an owner or creator could challenge a decision.
- The bill does not say how restoration costs would be divided if more than one person is liable.
- It refers to civil penalties without specifying their amount. The current code provisions and any existing penalty amounts are not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what penalties would apply.
- The bill does not say how DOT would handle a community board’s comments if it disagrees with them.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address curb cuts made without permits by requiring DOT to investigate complaints, order correction, and restore the curb if the violation remains.
- A possible argument for the notification and inspection rules is that they give the local community board a chance to comment before DOT approves a new curb cut.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill sets firm deadlines for DOT but gives no funding or staffing estimate for the added investigations, inspections, notices, and restoration work.
- The bill does not explain how disputes over whether a curb cut is illegal, who is responsible, or how much restoration costs would be resolved.
- Community boards can comment, but DOT only has to consider their recommendations; the bill does not require it to follow them.