Requiring the department of transportation to investigate vehicle collisions

Summary#

Introduction 606, sponsored by Council Member Rita C. Joseph, would amend the New York City Administrative Code’s existing rules for the Department of Transportation’s crash investigation and analysis unit. The stated goal is to expand which crashes the unit investigates and require faster investigations and more detailed reports.

  • The bill would define a “serious vehicular crash” to include any collision for which the Police Department prepared a collision report, as well as collisions causing significant injury or death.
  • DOT would have to start investigating every serious vehicular crash within one week and complete the investigation within one month.
  • Quarterly reports would have to include more investigation details, including evidence and data, crash reconstructions, findings about fault and contributing factors, and information about similar crashes in the prior five years.
  • Where DOT finds that street design or infrastructure contributed to a crash, the unit must review the location and related crash information. It may recommend safety changes; the bill does not require DOT to make those changes.
  • The bill is waiting in committee and is not law. The available materials do not include the current full text of the amended code, so they do not allow a complete comparison with current law.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in crashes and the public: If enacted, more crashes could be investigated. Reports must not identify people involved.
  • DOT: The department would have to meet the investigation deadlines and publish more detailed quarterly reports. Police criminal investigations and duties under state vehicle and traffic law are not displaced.
  • General public: The bill does not require street changes after an investigation. It requires a review only when DOT determines street design or infrastructure contributed to the crash.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • DOT would have to conduct investigations and prepare reports, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Reports would include estimated costs for possible street or infrastructure improvements. The bill does not require those improvements to be funded or built.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how DOT would handle cases where it cannot meet the one-week or one-month deadline.
  • “Significant injury” includes an injury DOT determines qualifies, but the bill does not set criteria for that determination.
  • The materials do not explain how many additional crashes the expanded definition would cover or how DOT would manage the added work.
  • The text retains a quarterly reporting schedule with an initial date in 2022. The available materials do not explain how that date relates to the bill’s proposed changes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to bring more serious crashes within DOT’s investigations and require timely findings.
  • More detailed reports could give the public information about crash causes, similar crashes, and possible safety improvements.
  • Reviewing locations where DOT finds design or infrastructure contributed could help identify changes that may reduce future crash risks.

Case against#

  • A wider definition and firm deadlines could increase DOT’s workload, but the bill provides no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not require DOT to act on safety recommendations, so a review may not lead to changes at a dangerous location.
  • The bill calls for detailed reports, including findings about fault and potential criminal wrongdoing. It protects people’s identities and preserves police investigations, but the materials do not explain how DOT would handle possible conflicts between public reporting and those investigations.