Establishing procedures for public notice and comment on certain policies implemented by the police department

Summary#

Introduction 863, sponsored by Council Member Tiffany L. Cabán, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. Its stated goal is to require public notice and comment before the Police Department implements or amends certain policies. It has been referred to committee and is waiting there; it is not law.

  • The NYPD would have to publish proposed policies that broadly affect how officers interact with the public or enforce laws, along with a written justification, references to existing procedures, and relevant supporting data.
  • The NYPD would have to publish proposals at least 90 days before implementation and accept public comments for at least 45 days.
  • The NYPD would have to review comments, but revisions are at its discretion. Adopting a final policy is also at its discretion; if it does, the final policy must address each comment and explain changes.
  • Within one year after the law takes effect, the NYPD would have to identify existing covered policies and publish them for comment.
  • The process excludes anything that counts as a “rule” under the City Charter. The local law would take effect 30 days after becoming law.

What it means for you#

  • People who may be affected by police policies: You would have an opportunity to comment on covered proposed policies. The bill does not require the NYPD to make changes in response.
  • NYPD: It would have to follow the notice-and-comment process before implementing or amending a covered policy, and notify the Council Speaker, Public Advocate, Comptroller, and Mayor when it publishes a proposal or adopts a final policy.
  • The public: The bill does not itself change police enforcement policies or create a new independent agency.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided; no publicly available information on implementation costs.

  • The bill requires NYPD staff time to identify existing policies, publish materials, review comments, and prepare responses if a final policy is adopted. It gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • “Meaningful impact” and “broad application” are not further defined, leaving the scope of covered policies uncertain.
  • The bill does not set out an enforcement process or consequences if the NYPD does not follow the procedure.
  • It does not say what happens if the NYPD publishes a proposal but chooses not to adopt a final policy.
  • The current Administrative Code was not supplied, so the available material does not show whether any similar requirements already exist.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary says the process would cover policies guiding enforcement priorities and how officers engage with the public. A possible argument for the bill is that advance notice and public comments could make those policies more transparent.
  • Requiring the NYPD to publish a justification and relevant data could give the public more information about proposed policies.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require the NYPD to revise a proposal after comments, and it leaves adoption of a final policy to the department’s discretion. Public input may therefore not change the outcome.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “meaningful impact,” so it may be unclear which policies must go through the process.