Replacement of lead water service lines

Summary#

Introduction 870, sponsored by Council Member James F. Gennaro, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. Its stated aim is to require replacement of lead water service lines on private property; the bill is still in committee, so it is not law.

  • Property owners other than the City would have 10 years from the law’s effective date to replace lead service lines with copper or another material approved by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).
  • Owners would also have to give DEP a certification from a licensed master plumber that their property has no lead service line. DEP would keep these certifications indefinitely.
  • DEP would have to test a line for lead at an owner’s request, at no cost to the owner. It would also have to replace a lead line at no cost when its work affects the line, or when the owner notifies DEP that a child care program is located at the property.
  • DEP would have to offer financial assistance to eligible individual owners, subject to available funding, and conduct outreach. City agencies would have to waive permit fees for replacement work.
  • Owners who fail to replace a line could face a civil penalty of up to $1,000; owners who fail to provide certification could face a separate penalty of up to $500. The penalties would be handled by the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners: You would need to find out whether your property has a lead line, replace it by the deadline, and provide the plumber’s certification. On request, DEP would have to test the line for free. The bill defines property owners to include people and businesses, but not the City.
  • Lower-income individual owners: You could apply for assistance if your household income is no more than 50% of area median income, adjusted for household size. The assistance program depends on an appropriation (funds being approved).
  • Owners of properties with child care programs: If you notify DEP that the property has a lead line, DEP would have to replace it at no cost to you.
  • Owners whose lead line is affected by DEP work: DEP would have to replace it at no cost. If DEP fails to do required replacement, the owner would not be liable for the bill’s penalties.
  • City agencies and plumbers: Agencies would have to waive permit fees for replacement work. DEP would have to provide information in English and the citywide designated languages, including to property owners, plumbers, replacement contractors, and child care programs.

Money#

No publicly available information on the estimated public cost.

  • The assistance program is subject to appropriation; the bill gives no funding amount.
  • DEP would have to provide testing and certain replacements at no cost to property owners, but the bill gives no estimate of City costs.
  • Permit fees for qualifying replacement work would be waived. The bill gives no estimate of lost fee revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current Administrative Code, so it is not possible to verify which requirements or assistance already exist.
  • The bill does not say how lead lines will be identified beyond testing at an owner’s request, or how DEP will check that all owners meet the requirements.
  • The bill does not set out the assistance amount, application rules, or what happens if funding is insufficient.
  • It does not specify how the penalties would be set within the stated maximums.
  • The law would take effect 180 days after it becomes law; the 10-year deadline would run from its effective date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a fixed deadline would require private property owners to replace lead lines, rather than leaving replacement to individual choice.
  • Free testing and specified cases of free DEP replacement could help owners identify or address lead lines without paying those direct costs.
  • Assistance for eligible low-income individual owners and waived permit fees could reduce some costs of compliance.

Case against#

  • Owners would face replacement and certification duties, but the bill does not specify how they would identify lines or what help would be available to owners who do not qualify for financial assistance.
  • The assistance program depends on an appropriation, while the replacement deadline would apply to all non-City property owners.
  • The bill sets penalties but does not explain how enforcement would work in practice or how owners could challenge a penalty.