Establishing a commission on proportional representation

Summary#

Int. 0903-2026, sponsored by Council Member Frank Morano, would create a temporary city commission; it does not amend an existing law. The commission’s goal would be to study possible changes to how New York City elects Council Members and recommend ways to broaden representation and voter participation. The bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • The 11-member commission would study different election models, hold public hearings and submit findings and recommendations to the Mayor and Council Speaker no later than 18 months after the law takes effect.
  • The Speaker would choose the commission chair. The Mayor, Council Speaker, Council Minority Leader and each Borough President would appoint members; the Campaign Finance Board chair could serve or name a designee.
  • The commission would hold at least one hearing site in each borough, meet at least once each quarter and four additional times each year, and conduct an education campaign after issuing its report.
  • The commission would end 90 days after submitting its report. Its members would serve without compensation.

What it means for you#

  • Voters and the public: The commission must hold public hearings in all five boroughs and make best efforts to publicize them and encourage public participation. It must also conduct an education campaign about its findings and recommendations.
  • Council election rules: The bill would not change how Council Members are elected. It would require a study and recommendations, including on multiple members elected per district and seats allocated to parties based on votes.
  • City officials and agencies: Named officials must appoint commission members within 90 days after the law takes effect. The commission may invite government agencies to take part; the bill does not require them to do so.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • Commission members must serve without compensation. The bill gives no estimate for other costs, such as staff, hearings or the education campaign.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “proportional representation” or set rules for how the commission must assess the different election models.
  • It does not specify commission staffing, a budget, or how the education campaign must be carried out.
  • The bill sets a report deadline 18 months after the law takes effect. The Council’s summary instead describes a deadline 18 months after the final member is appointed; the bill text controls.

Case for#

  • The bill’s stated goals are to broaden political and underrepresented groups’ representation, better reflect city voters’ preferences, and increase participation in Council elections.
  • Requiring the commission to compare several election models, consider benefits and drawbacks, and hold borough-level hearings could give the city information and public input before any election rules change.

Case against#

  • The bill requires meetings, hearings, a report and an education campaign but provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.
  • The bill does not require the Council or Mayor to act on the commission’s recommendations. The study may therefore produce recommendations without changing election rules.