Establishing a quadrennial regulatory review commission

Summary#

Int. 0967-2026, sponsored by Council Member Julie Menin, would amend the New York City Charter by adding a chapter that establishes a Quadrennial Regulatory Review Commission. Its stated goal is to recommend changes to make it easier to create, operate, and grow businesses in the city. It was referred to committee on July 16, 2026, and is not law.

  • The commission would review city agency processes and rules on permits, licences, inspections, applications, regulatory requirements, penalties, and fees. It could also review other relevant city policies and processes.
  • It would include a small-business representative as chair, seven agency commissioners or their designees, and seven members appointed by the Council Speaker. The mayor and Speaker would appoint the chair jointly.
  • The commission must meet at least monthly until it submits its report, due within 180 days after it is fully appointed. The report must identify whether each recommended change could be made through agency process changes, legislation, or rulemaking, and must be posted online within 10 days.
  • City agencies must provide appropriate staff and resources. Commission members would serve without pay.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses: The commission could recommend changes to rules and processes affecting businesses. The bill does not itself change any business requirements or guarantee that recommendations will be adopted.
  • City agencies: The listed agencies, and any other agency or office the commission considers relevant, could have their processes reviewed. Agencies must provide staff and resources to support the commission.
  • Residents and the public: The commission may invite experts and other people to give information or testimony, but the bill does not require public hearings or set up a way to submit comments.
  • Current law: The available material does not include the existing Charter text, so what requirements, if any, this would change cannot be verified.

Money#

The bill requires agencies to provide staff and resources, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • It does not set a budget or say how many staff or what resources agencies must provide.
  • Members serve without compensation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “appropriate” staff and resources or “small business.”
  • It does not set rules for choosing the seven members appointed by the Speaker.
  • It does not require the city or agencies to accept or act on the commission’s recommendations.
  • The bill says the commission meets every four years, but also requires monthly meetings until its report; it does not explain the schedule after the report.
  • The committee name is not provided in the available history.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to identify city rules and processes that may make it harder to start or operate a business, then recommend changes.
  • A commission with agency commissioners and a small-business chair could bring agency and business perspectives together, while distinguishing changes agencies can make from those needing legislation or rulemaking.

Case against#

  • The commission’s recommendations would not have to be adopted, so the bill does not ensure that any rules or processes will change.
  • The review covers a broad range of agency rules and processes, but the bill does not set public input requirements or criteria for choosing recommendations.
  • Agencies must provide staff and resources, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost or limit on those resources.