Establishing an office of artificial intelligence oversight

Summary#

Int. 919, sponsored by Council Member Julie Won, is a proposed local law that would amend the New York City Charter and Administrative Code to establish an Office of Artificial Intelligence Oversight inside the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP). Its stated goal is to protect consumers from harmful uses of artificial intelligence (AI). It was introduced and referred to a committee on May 20, 2026; the materials do not name the committee, and the bill is not law.

  • The DCWP commissioner must establish the office and appoint its director. If the director leaves or is removed, the commissioner must appoint a replacement within 90 days.
  • The director must set up a process to receive and review complaints alleging that AI was used in violation of consumer laws. If the director takes jurisdiction, the director must investigate and recommend any appropriate enforcement action to the commissioner and Corporation Counsel—but the bill does not give the director power to impose that action.
  • If the director declines jurisdiction, the director must notify the complainant and may refer the complaint elsewhere. Complaints about a city agency’s use of an algorithmic tool must go to the Office of Algorithmic Accountability.
  • The bill requires an online complaint platform, a process to send relevant 311 complaints to the director, and cooperation from all city agencies.
  • The director must run ongoing consumer education, provide required materials in English and designated citywide languages, and review consumer-law rules for possible AI-related changes. The director recommends rules; the bill does not require the commissioner to adopt them.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: You could submit a complaint through the new platform or 311. The bill covers consumers and prospective consumers buying or leasing goods, services, or credit mainly for personal, household, or family use. If the director investigates, you must be told the status; if the complaint is referred, you must be told where.
  • Businesses: The bill does not ban AI use or create a new penalty. But a complaint alleging a violation of a consumer law could be investigated, and the director could recommend enforcement against the person complained about.
  • City agencies: They must cooperate with the office. Complaints about an agency’s use of an algorithmic tool must be referred to the Office of Algorithmic Accountability.
  • General public: The office would be a division within DCWP, not a new independent agency. It must provide education and information about ways to report harmful practices and available legal protections.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires DCWP to establish the office and requires a complaint platform, public education, and language access, but gives no staffing or spending estimate.
  • It does not state an appropriation, funding source, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The materials do not include the current Charter or Administrative Code text, so it is not possible to verify what complaint services, rules, or offices already exist or precisely how much this bill would add.
  • The bill does not set standards for when the director should take jurisdiction, how investigations work, or how quickly complaints must be handled.
  • The bill does not require the commissioner or Corporation Counsel to act on the director’s enforcement recommendations, or the commissioner to adopt recommended rules.
  • The bill does not say how many staff the office would have or how it would coordinate with existing complaint services.
  • The bill takes effect 180 days after it becomes law; its passage and eventual start are uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give consumers a single route to complain about alleged AI-related violations of consumer laws.
  • A required investigation after the director takes jurisdiction could help the city examine allegations rather than leaving them without a response.
  • Required outreach could inform consumers about deceptive or unconscionable practices, reporting options, and legal protections.
  • Regular review of consumer-law rules could help the city identify where existing rules may need clarification for AI use.

Case against#

  • The bill does not guarantee enforcement: the director recommends action, while the commissioner and Corporation Counsel are not required to follow that recommendation.
  • The bill leaves jurisdiction decisions and investigation timelines largely to future procedures, so consumers may not know what response to expect.
  • The office’s duties could add work for DCWP and other agencies, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill requires annual review of rules and recommendations when the director determines changes are needed, but does not require the commissioner to make those changes.