A transparency report regarding New York city police department security perimeters adjacent to educational facilities

Summary#

Introduction 0929-A, sponsored by Council Member Elsie Encarnación, became Local Law 2026/124 without the Mayor’s signature. It amends the New York City Administrative Code to require the Police Commissioner to prepare reports about the NYPD’s plan for security perimeters at certain educational facilities. The stated goal is to address risks while protecting speech, assembly and protest rights.

  • The Commissioner had to send a proposed report to the Mayor and Council Speaker within 45 days of the law taking effect, and a final report within 90 days. The final report must also be posted on the NYPD website.
  • The reports must cover considerations for whether and when to use perimeters, how long to keep them, and how far they extend.
  • They must also cover protecting speech, assembly and protest—including student walkouts—and emergency access; following specified protest-related settlement agreements; and communicating with facility administrators and the public.
  • The law defines covered facilities to include childcare and early childhood programs, elementary, middle and junior high schools, and nonpublic high schools. It excludes colleges, universities, libraries and several other named places.
  • The final report must give the public a NYPD point of contact. The law does not itself require the NYPD to set up a perimeter or create detailed rules for doing so.

What it means for you#

  • Students, families and the public: The law requires the NYPD to publish its plan and provide a contact point. It does not itself change the right to speak, assemble or protest.
  • Schools and other covered facilities: The reports must address communication with facility administrators. The law does not require a particular meeting or consultation process.
  • People protesting or entering or leaving facilities: The reports must address perimeter decisions and protecting access and protest rights. The law does not itself set a perimeter or ban conduct.
  • Colleges, universities, libraries and other excluded facilities: They are not covered by this reporting requirement.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Commissioner must prepare, submit and publish reports, but the materials give no cost or staffing estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The law does not set a deadline for the reports to be publicly discussed or updated after the final report.
  • It does not define “when necessary” or specify what the NYPD must do in each situation.
  • It requires reports to describe considerations for engaging with administrators and the public, but does not require a particular form of engagement.
  • No information is provided about whether the proposed or final report was completed.

Case for#

  • The law requires the NYPD to explain its planned approach to perimeters near covered educational facilities.
  • Requiring the reports to address speech, assembly, protest and emergency access could make those concerns visible in the department’s planning.
  • Requiring a public report and contact point gives the public a way to find the NYPD’s stated approach.

Case against#

  • The law requires a plan to be reported, but does not itself set binding operational rules for when or how the NYPD may use a perimeter.
  • It does not require the NYPD to consult with schools or the public in a specific way, even though the reports must address considerations for communication.
  • The law provides no estimate of the work or cost involved, and no update schedule after the final report.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 439762

    Passed49 members voted

    City Council: Approved by Council, Int 0929-2026 (A Local Law to amend the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to a transparency report regarding New York city police department security perimeters adjacent to educational facilities)

    FOR · 39AGAINST · 10

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    39For

    • Democratic34
    • Republican5

    10Against

    • Democratic10

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 440052

    Passed9 members voted

    Committee on Public Safety: Approved by Committee, Int 0929-2026 (A Local Law to amend the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to a transparency report regarding New York city police department security perimeters adjacent to educational facilities)

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Democratic6
    • Republican1

    2Against

    • Democratic2