Using micromobility dynamometers to test micromobility devices operating in the city

Summary#

Introduction 986, sponsored by Council Member Shaun Abreu, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code to require the Police Commissioner, working with the Transportation Commissioner, to set up a program for testing micromobility devices with dynamometers (tools that measure motor force, torque or power). Its stated goal is to help enforce an existing restriction on certain motorized scooters. The bill has been laid over in three committees and is not law.

  • Police officers could test a device only if they have probable cause to believe it is a motorized scooter, and the device is operating in a street, park or other public place.
  • The program must prioritize the 10 locations with the most micromobility-device traffic and, if different, the 10 locations with the highest collision rates involving those devices.
  • Each year, the Police Commissioner and Transportation Commissioner must publish and send the Mayor and Council Speaker a report on tests and specified findings about motor power, assisted speed and impounded devices.
  • The bill would take effect one year after becoming law.

What it means for you#

  • People using micromobility devices: The bill does not itself ban devices or create a new penalty. It would authorize testing under the program when an officer has probable cause that a device is a motorized scooter.
  • NYPD and the Department of Transportation: Their commissioners must establish the testing program together. The bill does not set out how tests are performed or how officers decide whether probable cause exists.
  • Current law: The Council summary describes an existing prohibition on certain high-power or high-speed devices. The text refers to the related Administrative Code provision, but that provision was not supplied, so its full rules and penalties could not be verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires a testing program and yearly reporting, but gives no estimate for equipment, staffing or other costs and does not specify funding.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set testing procedures, equipment standards, or timelines for setting up the program.
  • It does not explain how probable cause is to be assessed or how a person could challenge a test or its result.
  • The underlying law referenced by the bill was not supplied, so the exact prohibition and rules for impounding devices could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give police a way to measure motor power and assisted speed when enforcing the existing restriction, rather than relying only on appearance.
  • Prioritizing areas with high device traffic or collision rates could focus testing where the bill identifies more activity or crashes. The probable-cause condition limits when officers may test.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires testing and reporting but leaves key procedures—such as equipment standards and how test results are handled—to be worked out later.
  • The bill requires officers to select locations by traffic and collision rates, but does not explain how those measures will be calculated or how the two sets of locations will be chosen.