Reporting data about micromobility device crashes

Summary#

Introduction 1052-2026, sponsored by Council Member Vickie Paladino, would amend the New York City Administrative Code sections governing traffic data and bicycle-crash reporting. It would expand those rules to cover micromobility devices; its stated goal is to improve reporting on crashes involving them. The bill was heard and laid over in three committees, so it is not law.

  • NYPD would have to publish traffic-crash data broken down by vehicle and micromobility-device type and class, and by the people involved. It would also report injuries, deaths and apparent human factors in crashes.
  • The Department of Transportation (DOT) commissioner would have to compile micromobility crashes reported to city agencies, consulting NYPD, the Fire Department, the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, NYC Health + Hospitals and any other relevant entity.
  • By June 1 each year, the commissioner would have to report the previous calendar year’s crash totals, broken down by crash type, and post the report online.
  • DOT would have to maintain an interactive map of crash data with valid location information and update it at least monthly. Reports and compilations must cite data sources; additional breakdowns are required only to the extent the information is available.
  • The bill defines micromobility devices broadly to include bicycles, electric-assist bicycles, scooters and electric scooters, among other devices intended for personal transport that are not motor vehicles.

What it means for you#

  • The public: If enacted, the bill would require more public crash data and an online map. It would not itself change traffic rules or create a new service for riders.
  • City agencies: NYPD would have to publish the specified traffic data. The DOT commissioner would have to compile, report and map data, with input from the named agencies.
  • People involved in crashes: The bill concerns reporting about crashes reported to city agencies; it does not require people to file a new report or apply for anything.
  • Current law: The supplied text shows that existing rules cover bicycle-crash data. It also appears to replace required injury, fatality, borough and precinct breakdowns in the annual report with breakdowns required only when the commissioner has the information. The current parent law was not supplied, so this comparison could not be independently verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require agency reporting, consultation and map updates, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a specific schedule for NYPD’s website updates.
  • It does not require agencies to collect information that is unavailable to the DOT commissioner; how complete the resulting data would be is unclear.
  • It does not set rules for checking data quality or resolving differences between agency records.
  • It takes effect immediately if enacted, but the bill is still laid over in committee.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make crash information about more than bicycles visible to the public.
  • A yearly report and monthly map could make it easier to see where and how reported crashes occur.
  • Requiring consultation across agencies could bring together data held by different parts of city government.

Case against#

  • One concern is that important breakdowns are required only when the information is available, so reports may omit injuries, deaths, location, time or device type.
  • The bill does not establish common data-collection or verification rules, which could limit how complete or comparable agency data are.
  • The bill requires continuing agency work but provides no cost or staffing estimate.