Installation of sidewalk riding detection technology on electric bicycles and electric scooters that are part of share systems

Summary#

Int. 1102-2026 would amend the New York City Administrative Code to require sidewalk-riding detection technology and a linked stopping feature on every electric bicycle and electric scooter in a self-service share system. The bill’s stated subject is installing this technology; it does not state a separate goal. Prime sponsor: Shaun Abreu. The bill is referred to committee and is not law.

  • Share-system owners and operators must install and maintain working detection technology on each device.
  • They must ensure each device gradually slows to a stop when it mounts or rides on a sidewalk, until it fully leaves the sidewalk.
  • The first violation carries a $0 civil penalty. A later violation can carry a penalty of up to $1,000 if it is for the same violation, is cited on a different day, and occurs within two years of the first violation.
  • The law would take effect one year after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • Share-system owners and operators: They would have to equip and maintain every electric bicycle and scooter in their system, and ensure the stopping feature works.
  • People riding shared devices: The device would gradually slow to a stop if it detects that it has mounted or is riding on a sidewalk. The bill does not set a penalty for riders.
  • People using private devices: The bill applies to devices in a defined self-service share system, not all privately owned e-bikes and scooters.
  • People whose location data may be collected: GPS-based detection is one allowed method and can collect, store, and transmit location data. The bill does not require GPS specifically; it also lists other detection methods.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost.

  • Owners and operators would have to pay to install and maintain the technology; the bill gives no estimate.
  • The first civil penalty is $0. Later qualifying violations carry a penalty of up to $1,000.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not name the city agency that would enforce the requirements or explain how violations would be identified, cited, or challenged.
  • It sets no technical standards, testing rules, or exceptions for the detection and stopping features.
  • It does not set privacy rules for location data or explain how long data could be kept or who could access it.
  • The supplied history lists hearings and committee layovers on September 30, before the October 8 introduction and referral. The record does not explain this timeline inconsistency.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that detecting sidewalk riding and slowing shared devices could help limit conflicts between moving devices and pedestrians.
  • The bill applies the requirements to every device in a share system, rather than leaving installation and upkeep to each rider.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires costly equipment and ongoing maintenance without setting technical standards or providing an estimate of the burden on operators.
  • The bill does not explain how a device will distinguish sidewalk riding from other movement, or how operators can contest a violation.
  • Its allowance for location-tracking technology includes collecting, storing, and transmitting geographical data, but the bill sets no privacy safeguards.