Requiring large private businesses to enable their customers to connect to a human customer service agent

Summary#

Int. 1187-2026, sponsored by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require certain large businesses to offer customers a way to request a human agent; its stated purpose is to make human customer service available to New York City customers. The bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • It covers private businesses with more than $500 million in gross annual revenue nationally that serve customers who live in the city.
  • Covered businesses would have to offer a single-step way to request an agent on the platforms where they provide customer service during regular business hours.
  • They would have to make a good-faith effort to connect customers within 15 minutes or offer a specific appointment within one business day.
  • Chatbot providers would have to disclose that users are interacting with a chatbot, with accessible, readable notice in the user’s language.
  • The Mayor-designated agency, or the agency referred to as “the department” in the bill, would have to make rules. The bill does not name which agency that is.

What it means for you#

  • New York City customers: The bill defines customers as city residents whose account address is in the city. If the bill becomes law, covered businesses would have to provide a single-step transfer option during regular business hours. The 15-minute connection or one-business-day appointment is a good-faith-effort standard, not a guarantee.
  • Customers using chatbots: A notice would have to appear before the chatbot’s first response, every hour afterward, and whenever a user asks if it is human. Notice must be accessible, readable, and in the language the customer is using.
  • Large businesses: They could not claim customer service is available through a platform they do not provide. A business that serves city customers online and has telephone customer service would have to display its phone number clearly on its website.
  • Businesses’ limits and exceptions: The bill does not require a business to add a platform it did not already offer, or to start telephone service if it had none when the law takes effect. It also exempts email, web forms, and voicemail from the 15-minute response target, and provides exceptions for certain emergencies and outages.
  • Businesses and the public: Violations could bring civil penalties of up to $5,000 for an initial violation and up to $10,000 for each later violation. The Corporation Counsel, or designated people acting on behalf of the department, could bring court proceedings to seek compliance or other relief.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires the responsible agency to make rules, but gives no estimate for staffing or other public costs.
  • Covered businesses may need to change customer-service systems or staffing; the bill gives no estimate of those costs.
  • The maximum civil penalties are $5,000 for an initial violation and $10,000 for each subsequent violation.
  • If enacted, the local law would take effect 180 days after it becomes law.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not name the agency meant by “the department”; the Mayor could designate another agency or office.
  • The bill does not set the agency’s rules, including detailed enforcement procedures.
  • “Good faith effort” is tied to commercially reasonable and practicable standards, but the bill does not state what standards would qualify in particular cases.
  • The bill does not explain how the $500 million revenue threshold would be measured or which business records would establish it.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that customers should have a clear way to reach a person when they need help with accounts, billing, complaints, refunds, cancellations, fraud claims, or disputes.
  • A single-step transfer option could make it easier to request a human agent without going through more automated prompts.
  • Clear chatbot notices could help customers know whether they are speaking with a person or an automated system.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill’s good-faith standard does not guarantee a customer will reach an agent within 15 minutes or receive an appointment within one business day.
  • Covered businesses may face costs to change their customer-service platforms or staffing, but the bill gives no estimate.
  • The responsible agency and detailed rules are not specified in the bill, leaving important implementation and enforcement details for later.