Summary#
S-10736 would amend New York’s Executive Law, Highway Law and State Finance Law. It would require the Department of State to create a catalog of preapproved housing plans, set rules for some lot splits and housing approvals, and create a fund for eligible municipalities. Its stated goal is to support housing and communities; it is not yet law and has been referred to the Senate Rules Committee.
- The Department of State must publish construction-ready plans for accessory dwelling units, single-family homes, cottage courts of up to six homes, and two-, four-, six- and eight-unit dwellings. It must hold public hearings when developing the plans and update them every two years.
- The department must set plan dimensions for lot sizes and the maximum parking spaces a municipality may require for each housing type.
- Municipalities must approve housing applications that meet the bill’s objective requirements and use a catalog plan. Municipalities seeking NEST certification must allow by-right permits for catalog housing on equivalent lot sizes and adopt rules for ministerial lot splits or zoning changes for catalog projects.
- The bill sets limits on local review of qualifying lot splits, but only on certain previously disturbed land and subject to conditions including rules about agricultural use, flood risk and public-road frontage.
- The state may withhold up to half of certain highway aid from municipalities that are not NEST-certified or do not comply. The money would go to a new state fund, which may pay NEST communities for infrastructure improvements and housing creation.
- The Department of State must study fire-safety requirements for three- through six-family homes and report within a year after the bill takes effect. The study does not itself change the residential code.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities: They would have to follow the plan-approval and, where applicable, lot-split rules to qualify for NEST status and related funding. Some local public hearings and stricter procedures for qualifying lot splits would be barred.
- Builders and property owners: They could use catalog plans. A municipality would have to approve an application that objectively meets the bill’s requirements. The lot-split rules apply only to land meeting the bill’s conditions; they do not cover all land.
- Residents and people seeking housing: The bill does not create a direct right to a home, rent assistance, or lower housing prices. Affordability is a stated planning aim, not a guaranteed result.
- Fire-code users: The bill orders a study, not an immediate change to building requirements.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost is included in the supplied material.
- The bill authorizes a new fund, which could receive appropriations, grants, gifts and money withheld from municipal highway aid. It sets no funding amount.
- The state could reduce certain highway aid by up to half and use the withheld money for the fund. The bill does not estimate the effect on municipalities or the state.
- The bill requires department staff to create and update plans, hold hearings and conduct a study, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so it does not show how these rules compare with current law or existing highway-aid rules.
- The bill does not set application timelines, appeal rights, or a process for disputes over whether a project meets objective standards.
- Terms such as “equivalent local substitute” and “adequate concern” about contamination are not defined in the supplied text. The Secretary of State may further define housing types by regulation.
- The bill does not say how much money the fund will receive, how payments to NEST communities will be decided, or whether any community is likely to receive money.
- The bill’s title refers to a study of three-, four- and six-family homes, while the study text also includes five-family homes.
Case for#
- A shared set of construction-ready plans could give municipalities and builders a common starting point for housing proposals.
- By-right approval for projects that meet stated standards could reduce local barriers to building these specific housing types.
- Directing some highway aid toward a housing infrastructure fund could support roads or other infrastructure needed for housing in communities that meet the bill’s conditions.
- The fire-safety study could inform whether code requirements for smaller multi-family buildings should change, without changing them before the study is complete.
Case against#
- The bill would limit local discretion over qualifying lot splits, including barring hearings and stricter local procedures in some cases. Some may see this as reducing local control over land-use decisions.
- Municipalities that are not certified or do not comply could lose up to half of certain highway aid. The bill does not explain how that reduction would affect local services or how much funding might be redirected.
- The bill requires plan updates and a study but does not set their budgets, staffing levels, or detailed oversight and appeal processes.
- Catalog plans and approval rules do not guarantee that housing will be affordable, built, or supported by enough local infrastructure.