Town would regulate navigational aids in local waters

Summary#

H-1218, Navigable Waters/Pine Knoll Shores, is a local bill that would give Pine Knoll Shores authority to make and enforce ordinances about navigation aids and markers in specified local waters. Its stated goal is to let the town place and maintain those aids and markers. The bill passed the North Carolina House but is not yet law.

  • The town could regulate placement and maintenance of channel, anchoring, and other navigation aids and markers in canals and Bogue Sound within its town limits and extraterritorial jurisdiction.
  • Any aids and markers must conform to the U.S. Aids to Navigation System and applicable North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission rules.
  • Before placement, the Town Board must identify locations by GPS coordinates in an ordinance and give written notice to the U.S. Coast Guard and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers at least six weeks in advance. The bill does not require those agencies to approve the placement.
  • Town law enforcement officers, Carteret County sheriff’s officers, and Wildlife Resources Commission officers could enforce local ordinances under the bill.
  • State or federal rules would prevail over a local ordinance where they conflict. The bill says its authority is intended to supersede a state statute for these waters, but the text of that statute was not supplied for comparison.

What it means for you#

  • Town government: The town may adopt ordinances and place or maintain the listed aids and markers; it is not required to do so. The bill does not itself place any markers.
  • People using these waters: As an inference, you may encounter aids or markers placed under a town ordinance. The bill does not itself ban anchoring or create other direct rules for water users.
  • Law enforcement: The named officers would have authority to enforce ordinances adopted under the bill. The bill does not set out specific penalties.
  • Other governments and agencies: The town must notify the Coast Guard and Army Corps before placement, but the bill does not give them an approval role. State and federal rules still control if there is a conflict.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost is in the supplied material.

  • The bill contains no spending amount or staffing estimate.
  • It does not set fees or fines. It allows ordinance enforcement under an existing state law, but that law was not supplied, so its enforcement details could not be checked.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the state law the bill says it would supersede was not supplied. I could not verify what authority already exists or precisely what would change.
  • The bill does not define “navigable waters” or explain how the town would decide where aids and markers are needed.
  • It does not require public input, set a review or appeal process, or state how the town would handle objections.
  • The bill does not say whether other permits or approvals may be required under state or federal rules.
  • The start date would be when the bill becomes law; it has not yet become law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the town could make local decisions about markers for canals and Bogue Sound in its jurisdiction.
  • The advance written notice and GPS locations could help federal agencies know where the town plans to place aids.
  • Requiring conformity with navigation standards, and making state and federal rules prevail in a conflict, could limit clashes with higher-level rules.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the town authority without setting out how it should choose locations or involve people who use the waters.
  • It requires notice to federal agencies but does not require their approval, which may leave questions about coordination unresolved.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate for placing, maintaining, or enforcing the ordinances.
  • Because the relevant current state law was not supplied, it is unclear how much of the town’s authority would be new.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1704646

    Passed110 members voted

    Second Reading

    FOR · 110

    110For

    • Republican65
    • Democratic45

    0Against

    8 members were paired and sat out the vote.