Coastal bill tweaks notices and fees

Summary#

“Coastal Regulatory Reform” is a bill to amend North Carolina’s Coastal Area Management Act (CAMA) and related coastal statutes; it does not create a separate law or agency. It would change notice rules for CAMA permits, raise the maximum application fee by $1, change some upland marina requirements, and clarify state agency roles over the Coastal Reserve. Its stated goals include clarifying notice requirements and agency authority. The bill has passed the state Senate but is not yet law.

  • Permit applicants could rely on certified-mail notice to an adjacent riparian landowner (a landowner whose property borders the water) after 60 days, even without proof the owner received it, if the required addresses were mailed.
  • The Coastal Resources Commission could charge up to $564 for a CAMA permit application, instead of $563; the bill does not require it to charge the maximum.
  • For certain upland basin marinas, applicants could use certified engineering models to show adequate water flushing when pre-project dissolved oxygen levels are above 5.0 mg/L. The Department would retain authority to require later corrective measures to meet water standards.
  • The bill changes the threshold in one upland marina provision from facilities for “10 or more” vessels to those for “more than 10” vessels.
  • The Coastal Reserve provisions assign roles to the Department of Environmental Quality, the Coastal Resources Commission, and the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources. The parent statutes were not supplied, so how much of this wording changes current law could not be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Adjacent riparian landowners: If an applicant cannot prove you received notice, the permit could still be issued after 60 days if the applicant sent certified mail, return receipt requested, to your tax address and, if different and assigned, your property address. Your failure to receive, claim, or respond to the letter would not delay issuance after that period.
  • CAMA permit applicants: The bill requires a temporary notice rule and directs the Commission to adopt a permanent rule with the same substance. For minor permits, applicants could use other notice methods allowed by law or rule.
  • Upland basin marina applicants and owners: Where baseline dissolved oxygen is above 5.0 mg/L, a model certified by a North Carolina-licensed professional engineer could be used to show the marina design will maintain dissolved oxygen at the higher of the baseline level or a level sufficient to support aquatic habitat. This is only for deciding, before permitting, whether aeration or other active measures are needed as a permit condition. The Department could still require monitoring or corrective measures to meet water standards or permit conditions.
  • Marina operators: The bill’s text requires financial assurance equal to five years of estimated annual costs for required water-quality technology. It describes bonds or set-aside funds held in a trust, with the State or permitting agency as beneficiary. Without the parent statute, it is unclear which parts of this requirement are already law.
  • Coastal Reserve users and agencies: The bill retains language on research and education as the Reserve’s primary uses and on other public uses being allowed when consistent with them. The extent to which agency roles or these rules would change is unclear without current-law text.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s overall public cost.

  • The maximum CAMA application fee would rise by $1, from $563 to $564. The Commission may set fees, and total annual fees remain limited to one-third of specified Department costs.
  • The bill gives no estimate of rulemaking, staffing, or implementation costs.
  • It specifies five years of estimated annual operating and maintenance costs for the financial assurance described for upland basin marinas.

What is unclear#

  • The current statutes and rules were not supplied, so changes to financial assurance and Coastal Reserve authority cannot be fully compared with current law.
  • The bill does not give an application process or appeal route for disputes about notice, model quality, or the Department’s written findings.
  • It does not explain how the Department would assess whether a model’s data or assumptions are adequate beyond listing possible deficiencies.
  • The cost of the new rulemaking and agency work is not stated.
  • The bill does not explain how its Coastal Reserve provisions would affect existing management arrangements.

Case for#

  • A 60-day limit could let permit applications move forward when an adjacent owner does not receive or claim certified mail, while still requiring the applicant to send notice to specified addresses.
  • Site-specific sampling and engineering models could let marina permit decisions reflect local conditions rather than require the same pre-permit aeration approach in every case.
  • The Department’s continuing power to require monitoring and corrective measures could protect compliance with water standards after a permit is issued.
  • A small increase in the maximum fee could allow the Commission to recover somewhat more of its processing costs, though the bill does not require the maximum fee.

Case against#

  • An adjacent owner could miss the notice and still see a permit issued once 60 days have passed.
  • The bill limits when the Department can require additional aeration or other active measures as a permit condition after a qualifying model is submitted; how that limit would work in practice is not explained.
  • Five years of estimated operating costs may not cover longer-term needs, though the bill provides no evidence about likely costs or duration.
  • The bill’s agency-role changes may create overlap or uncertainty; the supplied material does not show how they compare with current law.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1712625

    Passed49 members voted

    Amendment 1

    FOR · 49

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Republican29
    • Democratic20

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1712626

    Passed49 members voted

    Amendment 2 Motion 1 To Table

    FOR · 29AGAINST · 20

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    29For

    • Republican29

    20Against

    • Democratic20

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1712627

    Passed49 members voted

    Second Reading

    FOR · 49

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Republican29
    • Democratic20

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.