Proxy advisors face new disclosure rules

Summary#

S-1057, Required Disclosures/Proxy Advisory Services, would amend North Carolina’s General Statutes by adding the Proxy Advisor Transparency Act to Chapter 78C. Its stated goal is to help investors assess whether recommendations against company management are based on financial analysis; the bill does not require proxy advisors to prepare such an analysis.

  • Proxy advisors covered by the bill would have to register each year with the Secretary of State and pay a $100 fee.
  • When a covered advisor recommends voting against company management—or sets a default voting policy that does so—it would have to disclose whether the recommendation or policy is based on a written financial analysis.
  • If there is no such analysis, the advisor would have to notify clients and, for advice or research services, the company’s board. It would also have to post a notice on its website.
  • If there is an analysis, the advisor would have to tell clients it is available and provide it to a client upon request within a reasonable time. For advice or research services, it would also have to give a copy to the company’s board.
  • The bill would make violations an unfair and deceptive trade practice and allow certain people to seek a court order or declaration. It would apply to services provided on or after October 1, 2026, if enacted.

What it means for you#

  • Proxy advisory services: Covered services include voting advice or recommendations, proxy-statement research and analysis, and development of voting recommendations or policies. The bill applies when a company is headquartered or incorporated in North Carolina, or the service is provided to someone in the state.
  • Proxy advisors: A “written financial analysis” must assess expected short- and long-term costs and benefits to the company, conclude what is most likely to positively affect shareholder financial value, and explain the methods used, including the experience and geographic location of the personnel who prepared it.
  • Investors and other clients: You would receive a disclosure when a covered recommendation against management is not based on that kind of written analysis. If it is based on one, you could request it.
  • Companies and directors: A company’s board would receive the disclosure when the service is advice or research. If the recommendation is based on an analysis, the board would receive a copy. The bill does not require a company to adopt a recommendation or proposal.
  • Limits: The bill does not ban recommendations against management or require advisors to conduct financial analyses. It excludes banks, trust companies, broker-dealers, investment advisors, certain in-house services, and qualifying charitable organizations.
  • Enforcement: The Attorney General could use investigative powers under Chapter 75 if there is reason to believe a violation occurred, is occurring, or is about to occur. Clients, certain companies, and shareholders could seek declaratory or injunctive relief (a court ruling or order to stop a violation).
  • The supplied status says the bill passed the Senate; it does not establish that the bill became law.

Money#

The bill sets a $100 annual registration fee, but no estimate of government or compliance costs is provided.

  • Covered proxy advisors would pay the fee with each annual registration.
  • No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • “Against company management” and “reasonable time” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set registration procedures, review standards, deadlines for providing an analysis, or a reporting process.
  • It does not specify how the Secretary of State would enforce registration requirements.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of Chapter 78C or Chapter 75, so existing requirements and the full remedies already available under Chapter 75 could not be checked.
  • The supplied status does not say whether the bill was enacted.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to help clients distinguish recommendations supported by financial analysis from those that are not.
  • Making an analysis available on request could help clients judge the reasoning behind a recommendation.
  • Notice to company boards could give them a chance to provide information about a proposal’s costs or effects.
  • Annual registration and enforcement could give the state a way to address violations of the disclosure rules.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require an advisor to analyze a proposal’s financial effects; it requires disclosures based on whether an analysis exists. A client may therefore receive a warning without receiving a financial assessment.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “against company management,” which could leave uncertainty about when disclosure duties apply.
  • A written analysis must cover several topics, including staff experience and geographic location, but the bill does not explain how much detail is enough.
  • The bill gives clients, certain companies, and shareholders access to court action, but does not set out a process for resolving disputes before litigation.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1711563

    Passed42 members voted

    Second Reading

    FOR · 29AGAINST · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    29For

    • Republican26
    • Democratic3

    13Against

    • Democratic13

    8 members were paired and sat out the vote.