Judicial immunity ends; bipartisan nominations required

Summary#

HCR 3021 is a proposed amendment to the North Dakota Constitution, not a new law on its own. It would change rules about judicial immunity, when court judgments are void, Supreme Court rulemaking, and appointments to judicial vacancies; its stated goal is to remove judicial immunity and require bipartisan nominations. The resolution failed in the House, so it will not go to voters under this proposal.

  • A judge or other member of the judicial branch could not be considered immune from civil or criminal liability. That would not, by itself, establish that a person is liable in any particular case.
  • A judgment violating due process, state or federal law, or either the state or federal constitution would be declared void and without authority.
  • The proposal changes the Supreme Court’s rulemaking wording from authority to “promulgate” rules to permission to “adopt” them. The rules listed include court procedure and, unless otherwise provided by law, attorney admission, conduct, discipline, and disbarment.
  • A Supreme Court or district court vacancy would have to be filled by appointment from candidates nominated by a bipartisan committee established by law, unless the governor calls a special election for the rest of the term.
  • An appointee would serve at least two years. If the term ends sooner, the appointee would stay until the next general election after serving at least two years; the elected judge’s term would be shortened to account for that service.

What it means for you#

  • Judges and other judicial-branch members: The Constitution would no longer allow them to be considered immune from civil or criminal liability. The proposal does not set out the legal standards or process for deciding liability.
  • People involved in court cases: The proposal would classify judgments that violate the listed laws or rights as void. It does not create a process, deadline, or appeal rule for deciding whether a judgment violates them.
  • Governor and judicial candidates: The governor would generally have to choose an appointee from a bipartisan committee’s candidate list, subject to the special-election option. The proposal does not specify the committee’s membership or how it would choose candidates.
  • Voters: The text proposed putting the constitutional amendment to voters at the 2026 primary election. Because the resolution failed in the House, that vote will not happen under HCR 3021.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The proposal does not state a spending amount or estimate costs for staffing the committee, court operations, or any added legal proceedings.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current constitutional text separately, so it is not possible to verify which appointment and court-administration rules are new and which are retained.
  • The bill does not define “bipartisan” or explain how the committee would be formed, select nominees, or operate.
  • It does not explain who would decide that a judgment violates the listed laws or rights, or what process would apply.
  • It does not say what legal standards would govern civil or criminal liability for judicial-branch members.
  • The proposed change from “promulgate” to “may adopt” is visible in the supplied text, but the materials do not explain its intended effect on the Supreme Court’s rulemaking authority.

Case for#

  • The proposal appears intended to make judicial officials answerable under civil and criminal law rather than protected by immunity.
  • Declaring judgments that violate due process, law, or constitutional rules void could be seen as reinforcing those legal limits.
  • Requiring nominations from a bipartisan committee could be seen as sharing the role of selecting judicial appointees.

Case against#

  • Removing immunity without stating liability standards or safeguards could leave judges uncertain about when they may face civil or criminal liability.
  • Declaring a broad range of judgments void without setting out a decision process could create uncertainty for courts and people relying on judgments.
  • The committee’s composition and nomination process are left to future law, so the proposal does not show how bipartisan nominations would work in practice.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498335

    Defeated93 members voted

    House Second reading

    AGAINST · 80FOR · 13

    80Against

    • Republican69
    • Democratic11

    13For

    • Republican13