New option for school accreditation

Summary#

SB 2362 amends and reenacts North Dakota Century Code section 15.1-02-11, which concerns school accreditation. It requires the superintendent of public instruction to contract for a state-provided accreditation option and offer it to every public school district at no charge. The bill’s stated aim is to set accreditation options that support student achievement; it does not guarantee that achievement will improve.

  • The superintendent must periodically review how effective each accreditation option is at improving student achievement and school performance.
  • The superintendent may set accreditation rules and offer options, including a state-defined process and approved outside organizations.
  • Every option must meet or exceed state education standards and provide measurable student-achievement outcomes aligned with state goals.
  • A school may choose the option that best fits its instructional goals and operating needs, but the superintendent must approve the choice.
  • A district that chooses an accreditation process from the state-approved list is responsible for accreditation-related costs. The bill does not explain how this rule applies to the state-provided option offered at no charge.

What it means for you#

  • Public school districts: The superintendent must arrange a state-provided accreditation option and offer it at no charge. A district choosing a process from the state-approved list is responsible for related costs; how those costs interact with the no-charge option is unclear.
  • Schools: A school may choose an option that fits its goals and needs, subject to the superintendent’s approval. The bill does not require every school to use a particular option.
  • Nonpublic schools: The superintendent may adopt accreditation rules for public and nonpublic schools. The bill does not require the state-provided option to be offered to nonpublic schools.
  • Taxpayers: The bill requires the state to contract for the state-provided option, but does not set a spending amount.
  • The supplied status says SB 2362 was signed into law. The supplied materials do not give its effective date. The current version of the law before this amendment was not provided, so it is not possible to verify which accreditation rules are new.

Money#

The bill requires a state contract but provides no cost estimate.

  • The state must contract with an accreditation organization or vendor to create the state-provided option. The bill gives no contract amount or funding source.
  • A district that chooses a process from the state-approved list must pay accreditation-related costs.
  • The bill does not specify whether the state-provided option is included in that cost rule.

What is unclear#

  • What does “accreditation-related costs” include, and how does that rule fit with the free state-provided option?
  • What standards will the superintendent use to approve a school’s chosen option?
  • What process, if any, will schools follow to choose an option or seek approval? The bill does not set timelines or an appeal process.
  • How often must the superintendent review the options, and how will the results be reported?
  • Which organizations or vendors may be approved, and what must they do?
  • Because the prior version of the law was not supplied, how much of the amended text changes existing law is unclear.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives schools a choice of accreditation options rather than requiring one approach for all schools.
  • The state-provided option must be offered to every public school district at no charge, which could give districts an option without an accreditation charge.
  • Requiring measurable outcomes and periodic reviews ties accreditation to student achievement and school performance.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires a state contract without stating its cost or funding source.
  • The bill does not clearly explain how a free state-provided option relates to the rule that districts pay costs for state-approved processes.
  • The superintendent has broad room to set rules, approve school choices, and decide which outside organizations are approved; the bill does not specify decision standards or an appeal process.
  • The bill requires review of options but does not set a schedule or require public reporting of the findings.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1496822

    Passed46 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 42AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    42For

    • Republican41
    • Democratic1

    4Against

    • Democratic3
    • Republican1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.