Education savings accounts expand funding options

Summary#

SB-2400 would create North Dakota’s education savings account program and a new crime for misusing its funds. It would also amend the state’s compulsory-attendance law; the stated goal is to let eligible students use public funds for approved education expenses. The supplied status says it passed the Senate, but it is not law on that information.

  • The Superintendent of Public Instruction would run the program, or could hire a third party to administer and audit it. Parents would apply each year, and the Superintendent must provide application support and report suspected misuse to law enforcement.
  • Beginning with the school budget year starting July 1, 2026, annual payments would range from $500 to $3,500, depending on the student’s school or home-education arrangement and, for some students, household income.
  • Funds could pay for listed expenses such as private-school tuition, tutoring, disability services, mental-health help, and school meals. The Superintendent could add other eligible expenses by rule.
  • Participating private schools would have to meet listed requirements, including providing receipts and administering state tests. But the bill bars the state from regulating their educational programs beyond rules needed to enforce the program’s requirements.
  • A person who knowingly spends account funds on an unqualified expense, or intentionally fails to provide funded services, could face a misdemeanor or felony, depending on the value involved.
  • A participating home-education student would be exempt from compulsory attendance. A parent approved for the program could not file a home-education statement of intent; an existing statement would be revoked upon approval.

What it means for you#

  • Parents and students: Applications would be due between January 1 and June 30 before the school year. The Superintendent or its administrator must give an approval decision within 30 days and deposit funds by July 15. Applications must be made annually.
  • Families choosing an education option: Payments would be $1,000 for a full-time public-school student; $3,500, $2,000, or $1,000 for a participating-school student, based on household income; $1,000 for a home-education student; and $500 for a student at a nonparticipating private school. The bill also gives the higher, income-based payment schedule to certain home-education students enrolled in Center for Distance Education courses. How those home-education categories overlap is unclear.
  • Students with disabilities and parents: The Superintendent must warn parents that choosing nonpublic-school tuition with account funds is a parental placement and that protections under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act no longer apply.
  • Participating schools and education providers: They would have to provide receipts, comply with applicable program requirements, and not refund or share account payments with parents or students. The Superintendent may bar a provider or school for repeated accountability failures or failing to provide funded services.
  • Taxpayers: The bill appropriates money for program administration and possible legal defense. It does not state a total limit on program payments.
  • Current law: The existing text of the compulsory-attendance law was not supplied, so I could not verify which parts of its current exceptions the bill changes beyond adding the stated home-education/ESA exception.

Money#

The bill appropriates up to $6 million from the general fund for the 2025–27 biennium, and creates a continuing appropriation for education savings accounts.

  • Up to $3 million would go to program administration; up to $3 million would be available to defend lawsuits over the program when the state is a defendant.
  • The continuing appropriation means money appropriated to the Superintendent for the program remains available for account payments. The bill gives no total forecast for those payments.
  • Account funds would not count as taxable income to the parent or student. No estimate of total program cost, participation, or administrative staffing is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how account payments are calculated for each student beyond the listed amounts and income bands, or explain how overlapping home-education categories would be handled.
  • It leaves some key details to rules, including which additional expenses may qualify and how schools and providers are approved.
  • It does not specify application appeals, timelines for resolving disputes, or what happens to a student’s account if eligibility changes during the year.
  • The bill requires steps to reduce waste, fraud, and abuse but does not specify the audit schedule or detailed oversight process.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current compulsory-attendance law or fiscal estimates that would show how much of the appropriations may be used.

Case for#

  • The program could give families more ways to pay for education, including private-school tuition, tutoring, disability services, and other listed expenses.
  • The payment schedule directs larger amounts to some participating-school families with lower household incomes.
  • Annual applications, receipts, audits, and penalties for misuse could help protect public funds.
  • The bill requires a warning about the loss of certain federal disability-law protections before a parent uses funds for nonpublic-school tuition.

Case against#

  • Public money could support private education while the bill limits the state’s power to regulate participating schools’ educational programs.
  • The bill sets aside up to $3 million for legal defense but gives no estimate of likely legal costs or total program spending.
  • Families may face uncertainty because many operating details are left to future rules, and the bill does not spell out an appeal process.
  • The program’s use of public money across public schools, private schools, and home education could affect education funding, but the supplied materials do not quantify those effects.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1496837

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 25AGAINST · 22

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    25For

    • Republican24
    • Democratic1

    22Against

    • Republican18
    • Democratic4