Tax shift for school aid by property type

Summary#

SB 2363 would amend several sections of the North Dakota Century Code covering school aid and property taxes; it would not create a new program or agency. It aims to change how school aid and local tax contributions account for different property types, and how property-tax relief is shown. The bill failed to pass and is not law.

  • School districts would have to report taxable values and mill levies by property classification; the Superintendent of Public Instruction could not send a district state aid until it filed those certifications.
  • For state-aid calculations after June 30, 2025, the bill would use different levy rates for agricultural property (53 mills) and residential, commercial, and centrally assessed property (60 mills) in specified calculations.
  • County auditors would have to report school-district levies, including levies for sinking and interest funds, by property classification.
  • School districts’ local-contribution levy authority would use the 53-mill and 60-mill rates, while retaining a limit tied to the prior year’s levy plus 12%. The proceeds would go to the general fund for education-related purposes and could not be transferred to another fund.
  • For school-district levy questions placed on the ballot after June 30, 2025, the ballot would have to state general-fund levy limits of 63 mills for agricultural property and 70 mills for residential, commercial, and centrally assessed property.
  • The property-tax statement’s “legislative tax relief” line would use a revised calculation that distinguishes agricultural from other property.

What it means for you#

  • School districts: They would have to file valuation and levy information separated by property type. If they did not file on time, state aid could not be sent until they filed.
  • School boards: Their local-contribution levy authority would be calculated using different rates for agricultural and other property, with the bill retaining a limit tied to the prior year’s levy and a 12% increase. The bill does not create a new voter-approval process for every levy.
  • County auditors: They would have to report school-district levy information by property classification.
  • Property owners: Tax statements would show a “legislative tax relief” amount based on a revised calculation. The bill does not itself set an individual property owner’s tax bill or promise a particular amount of savings.
  • Taxpayers voting on school levies: Ballots for covered levy questions would have to state the specified general-fund levy limits.
  • Taxing districts: The bill would change how state aid is accounted for in a levy-limit calculation. The supplied material does not show the full current statute, so the precise change to that calculation cannot be confirmed.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill changes formulas used to calculate school state aid and local levy authority, but gives no estimate of the resulting state or local revenue changes.
  • It requires school districts and county auditors to provide specified information, but does not estimate staffing or administrative costs.
  • The bill provides no estimate of how the revised tax-statement calculation would affect the relief amount shown for property owners.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended laws or an explanatory note. It is therefore not possible to verify exactly which parts of the rewritten aid and levy rules are new.
  • The bill gives an effective date for the levy-related sections, but the supplied text does not state when the other changes would start.
  • The tax-relief calculation in the supplied text is difficult to read, so its exact effect on the amount shown for each property classification is unclear.
  • The bill does not estimate how many school districts’ aid or levy authority would change, or by how much.
  • The bill failed to pass, so it did not establish a start date or take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that separate rates for agricultural and other property would make the school-aid and levy calculations reflect those property classifications directly.
  • Requiring districts to report levies by classification could give the state more detailed information for those calculations.
  • Requiring a tax-relief amount on property statements could help taxpayers see how state relief is reflected in their bill.
  • Withholding aid until a district files the required certifications could encourage timely and complete reporting.

Case against#

  • The bill changes several connected formulas, but the supplied material gives no estimate of the effects on school aid, local tax revenue, or individual taxpayers.
  • The bill adds reporting requirements for districts and county auditors without estimating the work or cost involved.
  • The tax-statement calculation is hard to interpret in the supplied text, making it difficult to tell how clearly taxpayers would see their relief.
  • A district that misses the filing deadline could have its state aid withheld until it files, but the bill does not set out a process for resolving a filing dispute or explain how a delay would affect the district.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1499602

    Defeated46 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 23FOR · 23

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    23Against

    • Republican23

    23For

    • Republican19
    • Democratic4

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.