Insurance rules overhaul would affect claims

Summary#

SB 2374 is an enacted North Dakota bill that amends insurance laws, creates new rules, and repeals an existing section. Its stated purposes include changing surplus-lines search requirements and studying towing costs; the bill also changes rules for property claims, insurance producers, and group insurance.

  • Surplus-lines producers would no longer face the bill’s former explicit “diligent search” wording. Instead, a policy may be placed if the producer is aware that admitted insurers do not offer the full amount or type of coverage, or if an in-state licensed producer referred the risk.
  • Insurers may offer property policies with mandatory binding arbitration only if the insured accepts a separate written endorsement in exchange for a stated premium discount. The bill sets disclosure and in-state arbitration rules; the named insured’s choice applies to all insureds and continues at renewal unless changed in writing.
  • Insurers may offer a premium incentive for using a managed repair program, but must disclose the limits on repair-vendor choice, the repair process, the insured’s rights and responsibilities, and any repair warranty.
  • Before a named insured may bring a bad-faith claim against a property insurer, a court must first find that the insurer breached the policy and issue a final judgment or decree.
  • The bill sets one-year notice limits for reopened property claims and 12-month limits for supplemental claims, with a deployment-related tolling rule for certain service members.
  • Other changes include new disclosure options for purchasing groups using group deductibles or shared aggregate limits, changes to producer gifts and services, and a possible insurance-commissioner study of towing and recovery costs.

What it means for you#

  • Property insurance customers: You may be offered arbitration or a managed repair program with a premium incentive. Arbitration requires your written acceptance; the bill does not require insurers to offer it. Managed repair rules apply when the program offers a specified premium reduction or other incentive.
  • People making property claims: Reopened claims generally must be reported within a year of the loss; supplemental claims generally within 12 months of the insurer’s last payment for that part of the loss. The bill does not explain how these deadlines interact with other claim rules.
  • People bringing bad-faith claims: You must first obtain a final court judgment or decree finding that the insurer breached the policy.
  • Surplus-lines insurance customers and producers: The bill changes the conditions for placing this insurance and bars surplus-lines policies designed to meet a law requiring coverage from a licensed insurance company.
  • Businesses and group insurance members: Large commercial risks receive specified exceptions in insurance rules. Purchasing groups may use group deductibles or shared aggregate limits if they use disclosures approved by the insurance commissioner; the disclosure must explain how members may bear the effects.
  • Insurance producers: The bill permits certain gifts and value-added services subject to limits and conditions. It also exempts large commercial risks from some written-disclosure and recordkeeping rules for producer service fees.
  • Taxpayers: The bill authorizes the commissioner to study towing and recovery coverage. It does not itself require that coverage to be added to liability-only policies.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the insurance commissioner to report by September 1, 2026, if reporting findings and recommendations from the towing study; the commissioner may conduct the study. No study or staffing cost is stated.
  • The commissioner may penalize insurers that violate the arbitration or managed-repair rules. The bill does not state penalty amounts.
  • The bill sets no premium amount for arbitration; the insurer must state the discount in the acceptance form.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full current statutes or the text of the repealed surplus-lines section. The exact change from current law, including how the repealed search exemption worked, could not be verified.
  • The bill does not give an effective date in the supplied text.
  • It does not set a process, deadline, or appeal route for arbitration or explain how arbitrators are selected.
  • “Bad faith” and some claim-handling details are not defined in the new provision.
  • The bill does not say whether the towing study will be conducted, or how any recommendations would be funded or put into effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the surplus-lines change is that it may make it easier to place coverage when admitted insurers cannot provide the needed amount or type, or when an in-state producer refers the risk.
  • Arbitration and managed-repair disclosures could make important trade-offs clearer before a customer accepts an incentive.
  • The claim deadlines may give insurers clearer time limits for reopened and supplemental claims, while preserving a tolling rule for certain deployed service members.
  • A towing study could give lawmakers information about costs and effects before they consider a coverage change.

Case against#

  • One concern is that replacing explicit diligent-search wording may reduce the required effort to check for admitted coverage before using a surplus-lines policy.
  • Requiring a final court finding of a policy breach before a bad-faith claim may make those claims harder to bring.
  • The one-year and 12-month claim deadlines may bar claims; the bill does not explain how they fit with other claim deadlines or disputes.
  • Arbitration can waive court and jury-trial rights. Although the bill requires written acceptance and a stated discount, it does not set a minimum discount or explain the arbitration process.
  • The bill gives the commissioner enforcement powers but does not state penalty amounts.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1553099

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 46AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46For

    • Republican41
    • Democratic5

    1Against

    • Republican1
  2. Division No. 1494347

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 45AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    45For

    • Republican40
    • Democratic5

    2Against

    • Republican2