Dentists, insurers could negotiate non-fee terms

Summary#

SB 2375 creates a new section in North Dakota’s existing dental-practice law, Chapter 43-28. It allows dental providers to negotiate together with a dental insurer on specified non-fee contract matters, but only after review by the attorney general and written consent from the insurer and participating providers. The bill’s stated goal is to allow these voluntary joint negotiations; it does not authorize joint negotiations about provider payment amounts.

  • Before negotiations begin, a representative must give the attorney general written notice with details about the issues, participants, insurer, expected need and benefits, and compliance procedures.
  • The attorney general must decide within 90 days whether the proposed negotiations are authorized. The parties may approve a 30-day extension.
  • If authorized, two or more providers in the insurer’s service area may negotiate together on matters such as coverage conditions, utilization review, clinical guidelines, referrals, drug formularies, quality programs, liability terms, credentialing, disputes, and other contract terms not required by law.
  • The attorney general may limit provider communications and may request more information. A representative needs the attorney general’s express permission to act.
  • After the parties reach proposed terms, the representative must submit them for attorney general review. The attorney general must provide a determination within 90 days.
  • The section does not apply to dental plans serving exclusively or mainly people eligible for medical assistance, and it does not permit providers to coordinate stopping, reducing, or limiting dental services.

What it means for you#

  • Dental providers: If the attorney general authorizes negotiations and the insurer and participating providers give written consent, providers may communicate and negotiate together on the listed non-fee matters. They may agree to be bound by the representative’s negotiated terms. The bill does not create an application process for individual patients or require providers to join.
  • Dental insurers: An insurer may give the attorney general information during review. Its authorized officer must give written consent before joint negotiations can proceed.
  • Patients and other purchasers: The attorney general must consider possible effects on price, quality, choice, and access. The bill does not guarantee lower prices, better care, or any other outcome.
  • People covered by medical assistance: The section does not apply to plans providing covered services exclusively or primarily to people eligible for medical assistance.
  • General public: The supplied status says the bill was enacted. The text does not give a start date. The parent law was not supplied, so what North Dakota law already allowed or required before this change could not be verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The attorney general must review notices and proposed terms, and may request information or adopt rules. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill sets no fee, fine, payment, or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “independent dental providers” or “service area,” terms that affect who may negotiate together.
  • It does not set detailed procedures for the attorney general’s final determination on proposed terms, or say what happens if the attorney general does not respond within 90 days.
  • It does not specify an effective date in the supplied text.
  • The bill allows negotiation only on non-fee matters but does not explain how it interacts with other state or federal rules for provider negotiations.
  • The parent law was not supplied, so the extent of the change from current law is unclear.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that providers could address contract terms together when dealing with an insurer, rather than negotiating separately.
  • The listed topics include coverage conditions, clinical guidelines, referrals, and credentialing. Joint discussion of these matters could help providers raise concerns about care or administration.
  • Attorney general review is intended to weigh potential benefits against risks to consumers, competition, and access.

Case against#

  • One concern is that joint negotiations could reduce competition or affect consumers’ choice and access. The bill requires review of these risks but does not set detailed standards for the attorney general’s decision.
  • The review and consent steps could add time and administrative work for providers, insurers, and the attorney general; the bill gives no cost estimate.
  • The bill does not clearly explain the consequences of the attorney general’s final determination or provide a process for challenging it.
  • Because fee-related matters are excluded, the bill does not let providers use this process to negotiate payment amounts together.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1549212

    Passed46 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 44AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    44For

    • Republican41
    • Democratic3

    2Against

    • Democratic2

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1490674

    Passed44 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 36AGAINST · 8

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    36For

    • Republican32
    • Democratic4

    8Against

    • Republican7
    • Democratic1

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.