Vexatious litigants face prefiling orders

Summary#

North Dakota SB 2382, titled “Vexatious litigation; and to declare an emergency,” is enacted. It creates a new chapter in Title 28 of the North Dakota Century Code; it does not amend an existing chapter. The bill states no separate goal, but sets rules for restricting litigation it defines as vexatious.

  • A court that finds, by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not), that a litigant is vexatious must issue a prefiling order. It applies to people represented by a lawyer as well as people representing themselves.
  • The order restricts the person from starting new litigation or filing documents in existing litigation without the court’s prior approval.
  • The court must impose all costs of the vexatious litigation on the filing party and award the opposing party reasonable attorney fees and costs, including the cost of seeking the order.
  • Court clerks must send these orders to the state court administrator and each U.S. district court in North Dakota. The administrator must keep a list of people subject to orders.
  • The North Dakota Supreme Court must adopt rules to implement the chapter. Prefiling orders issued under a Supreme Court rule before August 1, 2025, remain in effect.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in civil or disciplinary cases: A court could restrict your future filings if it finds you meet the bill’s definition of a vexatious litigant. “Litigation” includes small claims, certain administrative appeals, district-court reviews of referee orders, and Supreme Court appeals. It excludes criminal cases.
  • People subject to an order: You would need prior court approval to start new litigation or file documents in existing litigation. The bill does not say how to request approval.
  • Opposing parties: If the court makes the required finding, it must award you reasonable attorney fees and costs for responding to the litigant, including the cost of seeking the order.
  • Courts and court administration: Courts must issue an order when they make the required finding; clerks and the state court administrator have duties to send and maintain order information. The Supreme Court must make implementing rules.
  • People in criminal cases: The bill’s definition of litigation excludes criminal actions, so it does not apply to them under this chapter.

Money#

The bill provides no cost estimate; it requires certain litigation costs and fees to be shifted to the filing party.

  • A court must impose all costs of the vexatious litigation on the filing party and award the opposing party reasonable attorney fees and costs, including costs of seeking the order.
  • The bill assigns record-sharing and list-maintenance duties to court staff, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • No publicly available information on total public costs is included in the supplied materials.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the existing Supreme Court rule or other current law, so it is not possible to verify how much of this process is new. The bill preserves prefiling orders issued under the rule before August 1, 2025.
  • The bill lists several alternative grounds for being a vexatious litigant, but terms such as “unmeritorious,” “frivolous,” and “unacceptable burden” are not defined in the text.
  • The bill does not set out how a person seeks prior approval, how quickly a court must decide, or whether and how a person may challenge an order.
  • The bill declares an emergency, but the supplied materials do not state the law’s effective date.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address litigation conduct that harasses another party, delays proceedings, or burdens court staff and resources.
  • A prefiling order could let a court screen later filings by a person it has found to meet the bill’s definition, rather than requiring opposing parties and courts to respond to each filing without that restriction.
  • Requiring the filing party to pay costs and reasonable fees could compensate an opposing party for expenses tied to the vexatious litigation and to seeking the order.

Case against#

  • The definition covers several kinds of conduct, including conduct said to hinder justice or impose an “unacceptable burden,” without defining those terms in the bill.
  • The mandatory order can restrict both new cases and filings in existing cases. The bill itself does not describe the approval process or other safeguards for those filings.
  • Mandatory cost and fee awards could add a substantial financial burden for someone subject to an order; the bill sets no amount or cap.
  • The list-sharing and record-keeping duties may require staff time, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost or workload.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1526449

    Passed44 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 42AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    42For

    • Republican37
    • Democratic5

    2Against

    • Republican2

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1492936

    Passed45 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 45

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    45For

    • Republican41
    • Democratic4

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.